Column: Weight For It

by 9

Benji argues that weight does matter (but not much). The following column will hopefully unite the warring tribes in mountain biking. From the weeniest of weight watchers, to the whatever-est…

There's more to this story...

BUT IT'S A MEMBER-ONLY STORY.
JOIN US TO UNLOCK IT AND MORE FOR LESS THAN 6p/DAY

If you have an account, please log in. If not, you can get access to some of our features by registering here for free.

A message from all of us at Singletrack magazine

For over 20 years Singletrack has been a source of information, news and entertainment for millions of mountain bike enthusiasts and as an important focal point for an amazing community of like minded riders from around the world. But it has also been a provider of jobs and income for dozens of families of our team as well as a source of revenue for hundreds of freelance contributors.

We want to keep going through this uncertain period and create great content to inform and entertain you, but we will need your help to do it. More than anything else we want to have a reciprocal relationship with you and the best way to make that happen is through our memberships. We’d love you to join us as a paid member of the Singletrack community – we promise you a return on your investment through the content we have and will create for you plus the numerous added benefits included with all our membership options.

Fresh Goods Friday 694 - Why UK fro...
Latest Singletrack Videos

Orange Switch 6er. Stif Squatcher. Schwalbe Magic Mary Purple Addix front. Maxxis DHR II 3C MaxxTerra rear. Coil fan. Ebikes are not evil. I have been a writer for nigh on 20 years, a photographer for 25 years and a mountain biker for 30 years. I have written countless magazine and website features and route guides for the UK mountain bike press, most notably for the esteemed and highly regarded Singletrackworld. Although I am a Lancastrian, I freely admit that West Yorkshire is my favourite place to ride. Rarely a week goes by without me riding and exploring the South Pennines.

More posts from Ben

Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)
  • Column: Weight For It
  • sargey2003
    Full Member

    Pretty much agree with all this, but (keeping with the programme) you don’t always need DH casings, so you can still have decent tyres that make life a little easier.

    oldnick
    Full Member

    My main thing is how efficient the bike feels. Unfortunately I had a Pivot Mach5.7 carbon, which for me combined magic carpet ride with no apparent bob when standing up. Nothing else has come close since despite lighter bikes, bigger wheels, slacker geo.

     

    weeksy
    Full Member

    My bike is red. Everyone knows red bikes trump all others. Weight, heck I’m many stone heavier than Schurter, hence him being quicker.

    LAT
    Full Member

    As soon as you introduce some sort of metric into your hobby, you’ve lost. You’ve turned it into a competitive sport. It’s become about Other People rather than You.

    well phrased and i completely agree, though i do like to know how much elevation gain there is in my rides.

    you don’t always need DH casings, so you can still have decent tyres that make life a little easier

    yep, it depends how heavy your tyres were to begin with. that said,  bigger and sturdier tyres feel much more comfortable and sure footed when descending rough trails.

     

    scotroutes
    Full Member

    As soon as you introduce some sort of metric into your hobby, you’ve lost. You’ve turned it into a competitive sport. It’s become about Other People rather than You.

    Well, that’s complete bollocks for a start. I’m very interested in the numbers but I don’t give a shit about how they compare to someone else’s numbers.

    And the main thing about a lighter bike is that it takes less energy to go a given distance, meaning you can go further on any given amount of energy. Of course, there’s a point at which fatigue becomes an issue and comfort often comes at the expense of weight so the equations change. The range of bikes being used for the likes of the HT550 shows how different folks have tried to weigh up those choices.

    steamtb
    Full Member

    I veer towards the longevity and comfort side of the equation on my heavy (by many standards) enduro bike. Pretty heavy tyres and inserts means I can run pressures that allow me to do a day at places like Dyfi, taking some big hits to my wheels and still feel pretty fresh and with an intact bike at the end of the day, coil shock adds weight too. My friend on his super light carbon bike, not so much. It also translates to all day rides that have ups and long downs, it’s a happy place for me and my bike. The bike flows really nicely on jump lines and downhills, although how much is due to or in spite of the weight, who knows. 🙂

    LAT
    Full Member

    Well, that’s complete bollocks for a start. I’m very interested in the numbers but I don’t give a shit about how they compare to someone else’s numbers.

    a fair point, grumpily made (wink)

    The range of bikes being used for the likes of the HT550 shows how different folks have tried to weigh up those choices.

    what is an example of a typical winning bike? or is it dependant on the conditions or the preference of the person who wins that year.

    i know what the HT550 is, but beyond that i’m completely ignorant, other than it being a long way from my kind of mountain biking.

    i once talked to a guy in a bike shop who’d just done the race that follows the rocky mountains (great divide?). i didn’t ask where he finished, but his bike wasn’t light. a steel 29+. though i’d imagine for comfort and reliability.

    pauldavey22
    Full Member

    I have to many friends that are or have spolit perfectly good rides, when chasing their own “Metric” which I’ve now learnt to ignore, it does make me laugh how much they can put themselves down for not getting the KOM etc.

    I much prefer the head up approach, see what’s around you and enjoy the ride. This is something I’ve definitely realised with a recent riding visit to  Snowdon with Wildbikes.

    What a epic view!

    jmmtb
    Full Member

    One point, often missed in weight debates, is that in the (my) real world of mountain biking in actual mountains we quite often have to carry our bikes, or at least lift them over multiple obstacles. Weight may not make much difference when pedalling at a constant pace, but it sure does when you have to hump your bike up onto your shoulders or over a gate.

Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.