We’ve had a Clearview Vision 500 in for 12 months and all through the last winter it has been fantastic (no heating on now, just light the stove in the evenings).
From all the threads/replies I’ve read on here, to be honest I think most people are happy with their stove and they all probably perform at much the same level.
One factor that some people do not take into account is how the stove is constructed – they used to be soley cast iron, but an increasing number are made of steel plate. The main difference between the two is that cast iron stoves can eventually start to leak at the seams due to continued expansion/contraction (this results in the stove requiring ‘rebuilding’ to close the gaps) while steel stoves are welded and thus do not get affected by repeated expansion/contraction.
Other differences between makes are probably looks, ease of control and after sales service.
I cannot comment on other makes but I bought our Clearview on eBay and refurbished it myself (simply cleaned, resprayed and installed new firebricks/door seal). When I phoned Clearview about the door handle that was a bit worn they sent a new one free of charge even though they knew I wasn’t the original owner.
The reason I went with Clearview is that I’ve heard so many good things about them from people I know and that if I wanted to sell it (which I wont) I’ll probably get my money back or better.
I’m sure the other stoves are great (I have mates with Morso and Charnwood) and whatever you get I’m sure you’ll be happy with it.
Just don’t get one from Machine Mart!