I’ve been running a charge spoon saddle and get on with them well but was wondering what other brands models have a very similar shape

Ok it’s Christmas and maybe a more premium saddle is what the new bike needs 😉

MM

I’m getting on nicely with a scoop, after years of using a spoon
http://www.tritoncycles.co.uk/components-c9/saddles-c85/fabric-scoop-radius-elite-saddle-p10257/s27775?utm_source=google&utm_medium=cpc&utm_term=fabric-scoop-radius-elite-saddle-colour-white-black-colour-white-black-sefb99radelwbk&utm_campaign=product%2Blisting%2Bads&gclid=CI76xbyUo8ICFQUHwwod7DAAKA

They don’t look that similar but I get on well with my charge and spesh saddles in 143 size, particularly phenom ones.

Scoop or Knife.

Started on Spoons, now got a Scoop on one bike and a Knife on another. Shape is near as damnit the same. Scoop is more practical and doesn’t sandpaper your shorts away like the Spoon does, but I prefer the Knife – less weight feels like it makes it more compliant and comfier.

The Gusset R-series are very similar, plus they come in some great fabrics! I have the tartan one, its getting a bit worn now, thinking about the tweed as a replacement.

Knife could be a good call

What about fizik? Which model is like the spoon for shape/comfort?

Bontrager Serano is nice. Very similar curvature.

Madison flux!?

Madison Flux is nearly identical to a Spoon…

Agree on the Phenom. Wasn’t sure if I’d get on with it, but as it was on the bike, I thought why not try it.

It’s betterer than the Spoon I’ve got used to. So much so, that I may just replace my other saddles with them!

Mini MountainMutant would be grateful of the channel on the phenom

Madison flux is almost identical in feel.

I have the tartan one

me too, bought it just cos I liked it. Eventually put it on my black and red Planet X RT57. Looks ace.