Yes we had considered an S-Max, I ran one as a co car a couple of years ago. Really practical and very carlike to drive and although we liked it the Volvo seems to have more appeal for her, she has driven 4WD before so is used to the slightly cumbersome feel. Disco is out, too expensive and too big for our needs I think, friends have owned two and put us off with overall experience of dealers, servicing and warranty fixes.