It’s fun, simple and easy to blame the pilot. It saves the documentary channels from having to go into too much detail because everyone understands ‘pilot error’. And It gets everyone else off they hook, the manufacturer, the authority and he company.
It’s not that simple. The FO in question didn’t go to work to crash the aircraft. Multiple issues combined over many years to culminate in the AF disaster. It is naive and simplistic to say it was ‘matey-boy what yanked it into a stall’.
I am not saying that there were not mistakes made on that flight deck, there were plenty especially in the route choice through the thunderstorms and then the initial diagnosis of the issue. It’s hard to think straight when you’re in the tops of thunderstorms in the ITCZ – I’ve been there! But it’s so much much more complicated than that. The manufacturer and the training department of the airline are equally culpable in my opinion.
Rest assured that those of us who fly an Airbus have learnt from this tragic incident.