As one of the dark, pugnacious trolls from the land of song, I’m a bit beffuddled by claims of unfriendliness to outsiders. I’ve lived in or near to Cardiff for a very long time and consistently hear visitors say how friendly it is as a city and the surrounding valley people are famously warm and kind hearted. OK, North Walians and Mid Walians (who are a small % of population because most live on M4 corridor), in common with many country folk, can exude an air of suspicion but I wouldn’t say that they’re hostile. My grandfather was beaten for speaking Welsh, by a person in a position of authority, in a practice that was not uncommon and generally accepted. But those days have gone and the perpetrators long dead and you can’t blame people for misdemeanours of the past any more. I love to hear English accents at trail centres. It’s great to share this beautiful countryside – which belongs to ALL of us – Welsh, English, European, African, whatever….and it also brings much needed revenue to areas that are often quite deprived