Yep. Shimano M088 shoe and XT trail pedal. The rubber sole moves against the plate that’s intended to offer some extra support and squeaks enough to slowly drive me mad.
My M540 and DX spds are nice & quiet with the same shoe.
Certainly overpriced, niche and relying on a certain amount of nostalgia to make any sales, but if it’s OX Platinum tubing, it’s hardly going to be a boat-anchor* 🙂
*I realise you’re probably comparing it to carbon.
I’ve got both Spykes and BB7s. The Spykes are easier to set up and are a lot quieter in the wet. The original resin pads don’t last long, but they’re easy enough to swap for something better when they wear out.
There’s not a huge difference in stack & reach measurements between the two tbh. You might just fit one better than the other. Main difference I’d say is in the slightly more relaxed angles and longer wheelbase of the Synapse.
Best bet is to find a local dealer and go sit on both. Or at least compare geometry chart to your current bike
Did your friend observe you riding the bike, or does he just think the bike ‘looks’ wrong? It’s entirely possible that you might not have the ideal sized frame, but you’ve actually set it up ok for you.
The Straggler has a comparatively long top tube for a bike sold with drop bars, so should be ok. I use mine as a drop-barred bike, but would happily ride it with flats/risers with only a 10mm increase in stem length.