John with your front tyre how can it be a tooth rattler on the log shore?
Whilst on Sat I was out on my rigid SS with John, enjoying the trails and dropping myself in it with some Coilair riders, I'll be honest and say I like it on all my bikes, full sussers, hardtails and SS'rs. Only reason I usually end up on the Love/Hate is I"m local and it can get a bit same-ish with a bit of suspension.
Go with your fave bike and just enjoy it, you can always back again with the other.