I think a lot of people choose not to ride certain areas when they are in a wet and muddy condition. Others don’t.
Just because you can ride the ‘rocks’ and others cant and choose to go round them doesn’t really matter.
The route of the problem is that a lot of areas of the Peak District are very susceptible to damage during the winter months so riding there exaggerates it (so does heavy use by walkers and horse for that matter).
Like a say a lot of people choose to self-regulate and not go to these areas during certain months as there are plenty of other areas.
I remember Pook saying to you on planning to take one of your Pootles – so maybe 20 people across Cut Throat Bridge in the middle of a wet winter period – that a better route could be considered due to the damage you would cause.
To be met with the response – ‘I stick to the main path, rather than going round the rocks, so its fine’ even though that main path in the middle of winter is thick and deep mud.
Cut Throat Bridge used to self-repair itself in the summer, but it’s been getting worse (wider and deeper and more rutted) now for the past 3 years, as people choose to ride there when the potential for erosion is at its highest.