I have two commuters. A kona minute with drop bars and a cotic escapade.
The kona did 4 years solid as my only ride and has clocked up over 30k miles. It runs on fat schwalbe marathon supreme’s most of the time so can feel a little sluggish but very smooth also. Its been faultless. Its got claris 8 speed which again, is super reliable and superb value for money. It can carry anything and go anywhere.
The cotic came along last April. It has just ticked around to 6k miles and is brilliant mile muncher. It has ten speed group and hope wheels. Its also been faultless. It is about 2km hour faster than the kona for the same effort.
My Mrs had a surly disc trucker with a Alfine 8. It is a great bike also.
Its a buyers market.
If I was to change, it would be for a kona sutra or disc trucker I think but can’t see that anytime soon.