If you want to not have to worry about what you can and can’t do I’d say go surgery!
Had a full hamstring graft 8yrs ago, after tearing playing hockey.
3months of physio, back on the bike after that. 3-6months, gym, bike and normal activities. Back to hockey with a light, no metal support after 10months.
Have been playing hockey, MTB and skiing since.
Really helps if you have a physio that is sport based, they seem to be much more prepared to push you a bit further and understand the desire for it to be the best it can rather than good enough for day to day activities. It’s means physio sessions hurt, but they work!