My girlfriend lives in Newcastle, I live in Manchester, my Parents live in the Lakes, so those are the two journeys I do a lot by train. It used to be about £30 to the lakes and about £35 to Newcastle a few years ago. Then they re-jigged the cheap fares using some calculator that basically removed the cheapest fares from my Journeys. Then a month or two later fares went up by an average of 5% nationally. 11% to Newcastle and 15% to Penrith though. Fares have increased twice since then and they've introduced Peak and off Peak tickets, but they won't tell you when Peak and Off Peak tickets are valid. So now you have the risk of an argument with the ticket inspector if he's in a bad mood, because you're expected to be able to guess whether the train is Peak or not, different stations have different Peak times. Plus with all the ticket checks and automated barriers before they even let you on the platforms these days it feels to me like the people I am paying think I'm a criminal, which I find pretty disrespectful.
Anyway, so I used to get to Newcastle and back for £35-40 only two years ago, travelling anytime of the day, if I want to do that today it is £78.50.
Then you add in the additional journeys. I'm quite fortunate in that I live close to the Metro link, so it's £2.20 into Manchester (Though it rankles that I can't get a return for this journey as they're only valid on the same day), but it's a 10 minute walk, + up to 10 mins waiting as the Metro doesn't run to timetable then it's hit and miss whether you have to change or whether it's quicker to get off and walk at Market Street, so you leave the house over an hour before your train, trek across Manchester, then it's a 25 minute walk at the other end. I'm lucky in that I can leave work early on a Friday, but if I don't I can't get to Newcastle before 10pm as if I book tickets I have to leave plenty of lee-way to make sure I don't miss it.
The cheapest train fare is about £40, booked well in advance and buying 4 singles Manchester – York, York – Newcastle and back. Buying so far ahead isn't convenient and usually extends the journey by an hour to two hours.
Then there are the 'special' journeys. It's the weekend, so they're using the buses instead. For some reason. but the driver doesn't know where the station car park is. Well he does, but he's gone to the wrong one and some nut won't let him stop there for 30s to let people off, so you've missed the connection. Or the driver thinks the quickest way from Piccadilly to Huddersfield is via the Woodhead Pass. Naturally you've missed the last train out of Huddersfield now and no one will take any responsibility for it.
Or it's £37 return in the car, leave when you want, take as much stuff – even your bike – with you. No one treats you like a criminal or makes, the RAC will take responsibility if anything goes wrong.
It's not a difficult decision is it.
I read that article on the £1000 in amazement last night. The chap they asked about it said, no one had actually bought one. Of course they bloody hadn't, it was £1000! For a train journey. Look where you can get to for that on a plane. Train journeys should be capped somewhere in the £30 to £40 region, regardless of distance.
Can anyone explain the train vs plane economics in any sensible way? Flying just seems to work so much better, yet should be an order of magnitude more expensive. But is actually cheaper.