Thanks James, I didnt really want to hear that as the deforsters were all but ruled out!!!
Now its an open field again between these 3.
Sidi Diablos
(Have the road version and love them, but could do with the ankle strap being tighter, considering modifying them myself to shorten it!! Also a bit peeved that for a £200 pair of boots the dont have replaceable soles like the other high end sidis)
Spesh Defrosters
(I have spesh BG summer shoes, really comfy. so I know they will fit, defrosters not had great reviews overall though)
Shimano MW80's (good reviews, but have sizing issues and would need to try on 1st)
Think I am going to wait until the summer until i can actually try some on. Will have to put up with wet feet for a while!!