Any BMW has pretty trick front suspension, the strut is a basic mac but that’s not the worry, it’s the arms front/rear/ that cost £££ Wheels bearings are a whole hub setup. The E46 has a bottom arm and i can tell you now it’s a total utter c***t to change the damn thing. The thing that puts me off the E46/3 series is the under side is steel and rust (badly) just like every other car so why pay a premium for it.
I currently have a 523 which only manages 20mpg and E60 M5 which is brutal on fuel.
Parts on the 318 are fairly similar but not everything. Discs are smalller etc.
on VW’s some bits are just nuts. The golf/A3 are bad for back calipers seizing and they are £80+ But the brake pipe threads into them and they are a pain to get in/out without replacement. Access to the rear wheel bearing spline bolts can be a hassle without removing lots of other bits. Clutch is a foo*ing nightmare to do on them
Agree with the above. The Toyota 2 litre D4D engine is VERY good although i had to do the water pump on my brothers at 100K as it was leaking badly.
As for not expecting much for £5k…… You can get a E39 M5 for £5k which will wee all over most modern cars in terms of power/spec 400hp and more toys than you can shake a stick at.