I have mixed feelings on this. For context, I have two young kids in primary school, my wife is a primary teacher but I work in the private sector. We’ve talked about this a lot and also with her teacher friends. It’s tremendously complicated, I think.
I am scrutinised in everything I do, every time I present to senior mgmt., or in front of my boss, it’s scrutiny that feeds performance reviews and ultimately my career prospects. This naturally gives me less sympathy towards the teaching resistance to observation… however that’s assuming the assessment is equivalent and I don’t think it is.
I do think, that teaching is quite resistant to change and has a culture that has turned observations/ofsted in to something bigger than it is/should be. But, I think as lot of this is down to what Ofsted has become – a cursory review that outputs a (relatively) binary judgement in a mire of conscious and unconscious bias.
My other half, early in her career was in a school that was assessed as requires improvements (equivalent – old standards in place at that time) and took very direct and very unconstructive feedback that directly contributed to the schools rating. The experience took my wife many years to get over, and she confessed that on the way to the work on the second day she seriously considered crashing her car to avoid having to go in. This is someone who has subsequently been rated outstanding on multiple occasions and has led the introduction of new modes of teaching across her academy.
Which then leads you to why. I don’t honestly know and we talk about it quite a lot, trying to work through it all. Ofsted reviews are very very brief, taking an incredibly small glimpse; they’re trying to KPI things that maybe shouldn’t be KPI’d; the level of variance in assessment and quality of assessment is certainly not fair; KPI’s can be very much affected by the socio-economic cohort; the ramifications of the rating are huge – far bigger than they should be; a constantly changing ‘how you should teach’ as education becomes increasingly politicised…. the list could go on.
They’re not snowflakes.