Diesels are a different kettle of fish though FD – my experience has always been that you need to be more delicate with your inputs in a petrol to be smooth. Tractor engines are a bit more forgiving.. and you probably wouldn’t notice as much.
It’s not just full bore upshifts either. 1st > 2nd at 2.5-3 krpm is horrendously tricky to get right.
If you’re ever up in Newcastle have a blast – if you nail more than 50% of the gear changes up and down the box 1st-3rd I’ll give you £50 on the spot.
Youre right though BMW do it to protect the drivetrain mainly in the US market but now it’s here. As I said earlier there are literally thousands of threads about people getting them deleted from their cars. They’re a menace