there can be no all encompassing ‘fact’ about comparative levels of erosion as the variance in ground condition, flora+fauna, usage and traffic volume make every area unique in this respect.
The only approach is to exercise compassion and restraint in our (and that of all users of the countryside) choice of route. As part of this I see it as a responsibility of land owners, environmental bodies and the media to provide information as to these issues allowing us to make these judgements.
I will not pass judgement on the STW article as I have not read it, if it encourages riding in a very sensitive area such as the plateaux without pointing out it’s innate fragility then it is irresponsible.
The Scottish rights of access rely on a difficult balance between user stewardship of the land and the abuses by the few.
I mostly agree with TJ on this one, his nationalistic blinkering aside.