I think we would all like to achieve what you would like an dhwat is fair but I dont see how this “choice” will actually help poor or ill-informed people to get a better service.
How do you know? People make informed decisions all the time, but only once they know they have a choice.
Look I dont know that these current reforms are the right ones, I don’t. What I do believe is that health provision is just another service for which I am a consumer. A lot of people think the NHS is sacred ground and should be immune from market forces. I remember thinking like that but I have changed my mind.
If you work in the NHS and you see the world through a prism where public sector workers in general and healthcare staff in particular exist on a wholly superior moral plane from those of us who grub away in the private sector, there isn’t any amount of evidence that is going to change your mind. Me, I’ve worked in the public and private sector and seen plenty to admire and criticise in both.