Hmmm…not sure about those two. Maybe a bit too road focussed?
About half my commute is country lanes, tarmac cycle paths, and a couple of miles of city road.
The other half is farm track, cinder, towpath, bridleway, field edge track etc. Odd bit of mud, but not long enough to factor in, and if it’s been wet I detour to avoid that so I don’t turn up to work covered in mud and leave a trail through the office to the showers!
Carrying 10kg in panniers too.
Current tyres have been Michelin Trekker, but I’ve now lost confidence in them :-(
I have tried it on some borrowed 28mm Luganos, and it was very skittish on the off road sections.
I can only get 30mm tyres in without having to deflate the rear to get it in! So 28 – 30s needed.