Not too bad, but not quite there.
2 full backs is plenty so no Mr Payne.
Maitland is a better finisher and defender than Seymour, the small difference in their general attacking play matters for Scotland but is irrelevant against the kiwis.
Centres OK (Mark Bennett is injured), would love to see Ringrose in but we need some beef.
10s, Ford instead of Biggar. The pack should put him on the front foot and he gets the backs going well, he was a big part of England’s 18 on the trot. Biggar sits far too deep and looks like a numpty (which he isn’t) when the coaches tell him to take it to the line.
9s, would love to see Ali Price instead of Youngs, his delivery is less toe-touching/reach for the sky. It won’t happen though.
Hookers. Jamie George is the best hooker in the Northern hemisphere. Best is a good player but can not hit the back of a lineout on more than an occasional basis. Won’t happen again but Tommy Taylor of Wasps is a better performer than Hartley at club level.
Locks, Henderson in place of Gray. More mobile and can pass off both hands. If Ryan was picked ahead of AWJ I would be surprised but would not complain.
Flankers, Hamish Watson and SOB in and Tipuric and Stander (oo controversial) out. Stander was great against the Italians but just an OK ball carrier against all of the others in the 6N.
8s Toby in.
Henson and Ashton can swap stories in the bell-end club.
POM for skipper.