Well, my Shimano HTII BB came with the words "improved seals" on the packet.
Following the last round of the Thetford Winter Series, they've now got that slightly stiff feeling about them that bottom brackets shouldn't have. I've taken square taper through similar conditions (i.e. absurdly wet and gloopy) without any problem.
Once they finally disintegrate I might try an Acros, or even a Hope before I go back to square taper though.
EDIT:
Maybe the only way old UN72's are superior is in their fit and forget nature. As far as I can see, HT2 is superior in every other way.
Perhaps HT2 just can't cope with being immersed and square taper can?