Swapped my Disco 3 for a new XC90 D5 auto in March & really pleased with it. Easy-ish to get bikes on the roof by standing on the back seat with the door open & easily fits 4 bikes up there.
Fundamentaly I don’t think the XC90 is as well designed as the D3, but reliability really let the D3 down (not just my experience) and the new D4 is massively expensive.
Not sure how I’d feel about a manual box, I guess it’s personnal preference but I really think these cars suit autos. Used manuals are like hens-teeth so I guess most people agree.
Only problem I’ve had…… my wife decided to modify the side or ours against a metal post in the school car park. She drives past it twice a day FFS, so how the hell she ‘forgot’ it was there I’ve no idea!!
Mine is still on the original Conti’s and has just hit 12k miles.. maybe I drive like a girl!