Thank you Stoner, you put my point more eloquently than I.
Sorry Julian – you are wrong. Not one life has been saved by these drugs and never will be – they simply mean it takes you longer to die. If NICE says these drugs are inneffective thats good enough for me.
I wasn’t suggesting that a life had been saved by these drugs, rather that it was wrong to allow people the option of taking something that may extend their life if they wished to pay for it.
I assume from your second sentence that you take the utterances of every official body as true then?
As for paying to study the side effects, you can’t argue it both ways. If there are going to be side effects surely the person will have to live longer for them to become apparent? If they are going to die, do the side effects matter that much?
This is on a different level, obviously, but paying for extra goes on elsewhere: I heard a story that only basic wheelchairs were handed out at a certain place, but if you were prepared to make up the extra cost ON TOP OF THE BASIC PRICE you could have an upgrade.
Besides, life is two- (or more) tier – those who have money can have more things than those who don’t. Simple.