wors,
5 v Butcher, well climbing biggest difference pro pedal was off, 5 really does need it on, Butcher just trundles up all the hills no fuss, techy bits plenty of grip , pretty icy today so was a steady ride blasted it in a few places, to me the 5’s strongest virtue was down hill, and the Butcher seems to match it , if anything it was a bit twitchy compared to the 5 but quicker through the twisty sections, I think the wheel base on my 5 was longer , I had a couple of years to set my Orange up so it was perfect for me the new bike will need some fettling, I think a shorter stem more sag on the rear will get things better, I have some offset bushes which I may just try nudge the fork out a bit and drop the BB , but thats for another day,
My 5 was 30.8lb and the Butcher is 30.55lb so not much in it,
my fork, wheels , brakes , seatpost all came off the 5 so build wise it will be a similar weight.
To be honest they do feel very similar, I would say the Butcher had a more refined feel to the suspension, can’t wait for some warm dry trails.