I get a few records each year at Christmas and the ones that I think sound good on a record player and get played the most are:
The Beatles – Revolver
Paul Simon – Graceland
The Soundtrack to Searching for Sugarman
Grizzly Bear – Shields
Ones on this years list are:
Darkside – Psychic
Real Estate – Atlas
Aside from the new ones I buy each year I have a collection of mainly instumental hip hop, funk and some dance. If you like Aphex Twin I would recommend Ambient Works on vinyl. Also as mentioned above I would suggest DJ Shadow – Endtroducing and also any of the Ninja Tune compilations.