A couple of recent observation from me…
Orange ST4 frame and Commencal Super 4 frame reviewed in same issue of WMB. The Super 4 gets a slightly moany review about being weighty but rides great, gets 4/5. ST4 gets the identical review but gets 3/5, even though the ST4 frame is more than 0.5lb lighter. You'd assume then that if both are a bit weighty but ride great, but one is a bit lighter, it would get at least the same verdict or better?
Orange Five Diva, gets a minor negative for "not being the lightest bike on test", yet when you flick to the table at the end of the review, it's listed as being the lightest?