My car history so far has been Mk4 2.0 GTI, Mk4 1.9tdi and now Mk5 R32, all manual.
The GTI was great at handling but was no where near as powerful as a GTI should be and I barely got more than 40mpg. Wish I’d went for the 1.8t but it was loads of fun on B roads.
The TDI was very front heavy so went through tyres quickly but easily got +55mpg which was fine when I lived 30 min from work. I loved the car but moved closer to work so the car didnt eaven get a chance to warm up.
The R32? Oh dear mother of god. Sounds amazing, goes like a rocket and I’ve still not found the grip limit (been trying hard!). Downsides, I struggle to get near 30mpg but I dont care about that. Financially its a money pit but if you buy one expecting any different, your misleading yourself. As I said, its manual but i’d heard stories about the DSG reliability in the 07/08 models so stuck with manual. I’d prefer DSG as I find the manual a bit of hard work at times but due the amount of torque in the V6, once your above 30 it satys in 6th unless I’m playing.
As for GTI’s? More economical for what is marginal difference in power. The grip is good but I cant see past 4 motion now. I’d also go for DSG as most people are saying above.
If you dont hear from me by christmas I’ll be in a hedge somewhere in Hampshire with a grin on my face.