I think the question you need to ask yourself is “are the difference’s deal breakers?”
The differences definitely aren’t deal-breakers, I suspect I would be very happy with either bike. I’m mainly interested in seeing whether most people would lean towards one of them, as I’m having a hard time deciding.
Honestly I don’t know how much of a difference carbon frame and +10mm of travel would give. I’m currently running a 120mm hardtail so I don’t have a great point of reference. I do use a large water bottle at the moment.
I’ll take another look at how the geometry will affect the feel of the bike – thanks.
I do like the idea of supporting a smaller UK retailer, especially with Bird’s excellent customer service reputation.