I think you missed that comment altogether…. He was referring to the fact that Specialized always do inexplicably well in Future Publishing magazine grouptests….
Dont agree, if you do the research you will find some damming reviews for Specialized bikes too, esp the road lines.
Apart from that ive had loads of Spec bikes and ive loved every one of them, they arent that bad!!! Its a bit sad that some feel the bikes get good reviews because of some conspiracy theory, 90% of the range are class leading
Check out the archive on bikeradar, its not as clearcut as you think.