I’m visiting family without my own bike, so someone borrowed me a fat bike to use, a Specialized Fatboy with 4.6″ tyres. We did a couple of rides on sandy/stony/rooty singletrack very reminiscent of Swinley, but shorter and less armoured surface. I’d never ridden a fat bike before.
First ride I had 4 in the front at 6 in the back (I’m 88kg) and second ride I dropped them to 3.5 and 4.5 respectively. The bike was overall not too slow. It was certainly slower on smooth stuff than a normal rigid bike, but on rougher stuff it slowed down less. However when the terrain got rocky and rooty enough I was bounced about a lot. The handling was ok at lower speed, but above a certain speed I found that the gyroscope effect became noticeable and high speed chicanes were tricky. I barrelled into a series of corners and was completely unable to steer enough and ended up in the trees.. fortunately the brakes were good.
On loose climbs it was great as I expected. I could stand up and pedal on stuff that would have had me spinning out. I did a semi-steep drop into a chute with the saddle dropped, and the bike was very sketchy over the front but I suspect this was the geometry of that particular bike, with a steep HA.
Overall the bike was okay, but definitely slower and not as much fun on windy singletrack as a proper bike. Although the locals here in Wisconsin like the fact they are slow because you work harder and receive less windchill so you don’t get so cold.