Forum menu
TBH Alien was about 44 years ago which is mad and they did wait 7 years till doing the first sequel so it’s pretty old .
I don’t mind the prometheus stuff but it’s a bit too weird compared to the original and similar to the Star Wars prequels when people just wanted to see more Han,leia and Luke but got jar-jar-binks.
I can confirm that I will be seeing this film on the coming Wednesday. My friends and I are now discussing the pros and cons of iMax vs. normal screen. It looks like the more comfy seats in the normal screen is winning right now.
I thought it was great, would recommend!
I went to see this movie last night, I enjoyed it, big fan of the first two, pretending the next 17ish didn't get made. Anyway:
Some notes. No slow warm up into the action, which was a virtue of Alien/s. Painful exposition, whap straight up there for the monsters. Which I get, tik tok generation 15 seconds to get people interested. Very derivative of The Expanse in the early stages but that's not a bad thing SF by it's very nature is derivative.
Lots of vaginas. Just saying.
Also, sorry spoilers but it's been out a couple of weeks now, I think they cut away a bit when the baby/xenomorph went for his mother, breastfeeding surely? Too much nip for a 15 rating?
But aye good film, jump scares might work if you haven't seen the first two and know what is happening.
Also to finish, the female protagonist was super bland, I blame Taylor Swift, can we have some more grr please? You get it's all about angry women and childbirth yes?
Well, saw it.
I have to say that I think the cinema experience has really changed since I last went about 8 years ago. This was a "luxe" screen, but even then I did not expect so few seats with such large leg room and the reclining backs & footrests. So, for that alone, nice!
Film-wise: It's an Aliens film. I love the aesthete of it, the dirt, the old/new technology, the sound design, the music. Many nods to the original two/three films (maybe a bit too much fanfic nodding) and I approve of the casting choice of essentially unknown actors, but it does make the film seem a bit "young adult" and, if I am honest, for an environment where people are allegedly indentured and worked to death, they are a bit clean and healthy.
BUTT... It's not a bad film. I enjoyed it despite the things that made me doubt the reality of the Alien universe in some places (timelines, etc). Overall, worth a watch. I also ate enough pic n' mix to nearly go into diabetic shock
I really enjoyed it but agree with lots of reviews that the last 15mins could do with a re-write or mostly adding to the virtual cutting room floor.
BUTT… It’s not a bad film
It kinda is though, the first 20minutes or so makes no sense. There are flashes of innovation, but the 2nd act is almost entirely fan service and the direction it takes in the 3rd act is just there to shoehorn in some of the Prometheus/Covenant story-lines, and in of itself is bonkers, and while that can be good, in this case it's not really.
Agree the sound scape and sets are great, and at the end of the day - more alien. Not my favourite, but I can see why it's getting generally good press.
The inclusion of the Prometheus stuff was odd. I thought that even Ridley Scott had said that Prometheus was an alternate timeline/universe, so the inclusion by Ash/Rook of that bit was odd to say the least. It also bugs me that, if that is now true, why is ll the tech in Alien/Romulus/Aliens/Alien3 so shit and old compared to the holographic loveliness of Prometheus/Covenant?
One point my friend brought up was that, compared to Alien, Romulus seemed hectic. Alin had a single thread that tied te whole film together, building slowly to the finale with flashes of events that were all part of the build. Romulus had more, more distinct events that made the whole film feel like someone had tried to cram too much into a single film. I agree that this made it seem hurried and a little chaotic, but would just the "Go to station, get in trouble, leave station" part have made a compelling film on its own, with a second film expanding on the [cut] bit about the baby?
The fan service stuff seems to be 'the thing' now for classic IP. I dislike it, but it does make the film happen I guess. A shame it stifles really innovative creative writing and screenplay (or seems to).
Why didn't they stop after Aliens? Because money.
Prometheus was the biggest letdown of my cinema going lifetime.
Covenant was laughably terrible.
At least they gave us a couple of great Pitch Meetings though.
Still, much to my surprise, some people on here seem to like Romulus so I'll give it a go.
I saw it last night with my 20yo daughter - she's seen Alien and Aliens in the cinema, so knows the theme. She enjoyed it, said it was scary. I thought it was such a bland, throwaway film that I'm not sure I'll remember it next week. She said maybe it's because it's better if you treat it as a stand-alone film, but then that doesn't work with all the fan-references to earlier films - Get away from her, you bitch, Ian Holm and all that.
Somebody above said it seemed aimed at a YA audience, and that felt about right - everything was too simplistic, too Marvel-like. I'm amazed that Rain didn't start doing Marvel style chop-fuey on the aliens. Common sense and internal logic was thrown out whenever a good set-piece was deemed necessary. And the fact that they needed a constant narration of what's happening was really poor, That either means that the plot makes no sense - it didn't - or the storyteller doesn't trust the audience.
Sad that this may be the last Alien film I go to the cinema to watch. Most of the others had something good about them - this was just meh. You shouldn't get bored in a film like this, especially one this short.
Seeing it at w/e. Will report back…
Someone showed me the social media ****sters "guerrilla marketing" expecting me to be impressed. I'm not going now.
This load of American look-at-me errugh sick in my mouth cringe tossers
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/3y6LUgzCPzY?feature=share
Just saw on SM the actor who played 'The Offspring' - Robert Bobroczkyi - 2.31m (7'7") tall.
Not been to see the film yet.
Saw it. Crap.
No need to expound upon it when Ryan George does it so much better.
Enjoyable actioney romp.
im sure there’s still scope for sequels.
but I miss the more cerebral themes of Prometheus and covenant.
I actually thought it would pick up right where David left off in covenant.
I liked it. Not great, but worth seeing on the big screen for sure.
This day & age it seems there are some folk who have too much time to overthink things, be very critical & yet offer nothing up themselves.
Yep, i liked it....big fan of the originals but went in with open mind, didn't overthink it, didn't try to pick holes in it and came out happy
Watched it on Thursday night. Enjoyed it and thought it was one of the better films since the original two. Definitely a step in the right direction and the third act was a bit of a surprise. Still not sure if I liked it to be honest but the first two acts were great in my opinion. Describing Prometheus and Covenant as cerebral is a bit of a stretch. They were two of the dumbest films in the entire franchise.
3rd best Alien film. Good fun. Best not to overthink the plot.
Worst part is Andy yelling "Get away from her you bitch" for no real reason - I thought the other nods to the franchise mostly made sense and weren't overly in your face, but that just seemed to be there to get excitable Yanks whooping at the screen.
It's a movie about aliens in space.
Amazes me that people get so ****ing high-brow about this sort of thing.
I imagine they're also really fun at parties.
Thumbs up from me. Well worth the ticket price. Scary, fun with sufficient nods to the other films.
Nah, felt like the aliens were phoning it in to be honest. Threat was there, but not visceral.
It's now on Disney. Watched it tonight and enjoyed it. Love the low tech high tech that mirrors the two originals. Not sure the baby scene needed to be in there but they could hardly blow another alien out of the airlock again could they?
really enjoyed it ..... up until the stupid baby gangly alien4 type thing at the end
Yeah I enjoyed it very much like the original, yes almost to the point it was the same, but it’s what I liked about it. I was wondering if it’s leading into the Alien Earth arc.
Just checked, it’s not.
Loved the images of space. Wished I'd seen it at the cinema now just for that.
Fairly rolled along in a familiar-but-updated way.
Ian Holm looked a bit shaky. But then... 😉
Alien baby man was decidedly not scary.
It was OK.
Prometheus and alien 3 are better.
Enjoyed that. The same tech as the original Alien and Ash/Rook especially.
It's no Prey, but it's enjoyable up to a point. That point being when the big gangly chinless hybrid makes an entrance. Entirely tepid, slow and pointless. YMMV
I get that these organisms develop quickly, but Romulus went super overboard with that…last time the parasite is on for maybe a day or two and then eventually the whole explosion thing…this time 10 minutes is enough!!! Then it grows mahoosive pretty much immediately…
I still haven't seen it. I really should rectify that.
It’s no Prey,
Off-topic I know, but there's a Prey 2 in the works.
It's OK, but the best thing about it is that they made it look similar to other (much better) movies, so yeah, no real substance there. Doubt I'd ever watch it a second time. Prey was great, although what I really want now is an AvP movie that doesn't suck!
I get that these organisms develop quickly, but Romulus went super overboard with that…last time the parasite is on for maybe a day or two and then eventually the whole explosion thing…this time 10 minutes is enough!!! Then it grows mahoosive pretty much immediately…
yeah that was silly, I like the idea of the cocoon type thing so it could grow, but theres still a question of where it gets the matter from to get so big so quickly, it was a question the original Alien never answered it was just sped up a lot more this time.
I also dont get how they found the alien in a fused lump of rock? when last we saw it it was just being blasted out of the airlock of the shuttle by ripley
I thought it was better than say Prometheus or Covenant in that the characters didnt do the most ridiculous and and daft things at every opportunity to the point where no corporation would put them in charge of a whiteboard let alone multibillion dollar spaceships,
As a big fan of watching Alien and Predator movies (Aliens was on freeview last night, only recently realised Hicks actor was Reese in Terminator, just like recently realised Gary Dourdain from CSI is Christie in Alien Ressurection), I'm half wondering about seeing if we can do one month sub of Disney+ to watch Romulus and at least Mandarlorian.
Remember this big alien thing at the end wasn’t from the normal gestation they go through, but yes still grew ridiculously quick.
The alien that came from the dog in Alien 3 grew quick too iirc.
I also dont get how they found the alien in a fused lump of rock? when last we saw it it was just being blasted out of the airlock of the shuttle by ripley
backstory is that it was able to cocoon itself when blasted into space thus protecting itself from the subsequent explosion etc. similar to the way they make their hives I guess but it's not actually explained.
@cougar2 without thread hijacking, Prey is tremendous and well worth seeking out asap
Aliens was on freeview last night, only recently realised Hicks actor was Reese in Terminator, just like recently realised Gary Dourdain from CSI is Christie in Alien Ressurection
You should also look up Jenette Goldstein who played Private Vasquez, she was also in Terminator 2 as John Conners foster mum and Titanic as Irish mum, now there's range no wonder Cameron keeps casting her.
@cougar2 without thread hijacking, Prey is tremendous and well worth seeking out asap
Oh, I know.
I meant, I haven't seen Romulus yet. I have watched Prey.
Watched it for a second time last night and I still think the ending is shit. It was just Alien Resurrection but with one of those ridiculous Prometheus chaps. One thing that bugs me is why are mining colonies needed when they have fully functioning robots?
I think the plot would've been better if it stuck to the premise of need fuel cells from broken ship. Uh oh, things have gone sideways and Aliens.
The alien that came from the dog in Alien 3 grew quick too iirc.
Yup, IIRC in Aliens they mention they gestate at different rates.
Watched it on Disney over the last few nights, big fan of the alien and pred movies, but this was really disappointing. I only finished the movie last night, so I could post here, otherwise I’d not bothered.
I would actually prefer to rewatch Prometheus again, rather than this. The script wasn’t great, plot - you can’t really screw it up aliens+space+humans+gore, space landscapes were lame, god it couldn’t have been a lazier reboot if they’d actually friggin tried. Rubbish.
I'd like to see a prequel to Prometheus that fills out more of the backstory, specifically what happened to humans between inventing interstellar space flight and Prometheus to explain why they are all so flipping stupid. I think the event is known as The Great Thickening.