I don't think it really matters what the documemts say at this stage. The news says we can travel wherever we want from Friday and that's all that anyone cares about. The majority aren't going to read the fine detail.
Which I think is fine to be honest, wild camping isn't going to cause any covid issues. It might make locals in rural areas annoyed but that's not the same thing
wild camping isn’t going to cause any covid issues. . It might make locals in rural areas annoyed but that’s not the same thing
if you are genuinely wild camping in a way that presents zero covid risk to anyone then almost nobody is going to even know... However there's quite a proportion of the population who believe that you can wild camp in a van - and I would not be surprised if Police Scotland are encouraged to move them on / issue FPN just to avoid the "honey pot" issues.
How would camping in a van (definitely not wild camping haha) be more of a covid risk than a day trip in a van which is allowed.
Not enjoying Scotland being overrun by campervans but there's really no reason why they can't go for an overnight trip if they can go for a day trip. Again it's using 'covid rules' to avoid different issues. Laybies full of dirty campers is rubbish but it's not a covid issue
Because in a roundabout way its restricting travel as far as most people can be bothered without an overnight stop. So a soft travel restriction if you like.
Personally I can't fathon the mindset of someone who, being told they can go out and play 2 weeks early, proceeds to piss and moan that they're not getting to do something else for 2 weeks. I'm booked in at Inners next week, it would suit me down to the ground not getting up and leaving before 7 but if it means I can get a day on the hill without breaking the rules then I'll get an early night and just deal with it.
I'm taking it as notice that I have two weeks use of Highland Region before the hordes of trolley lickers arrive 😅
How would camping in a van (definitely not wild camping haha) be more of a covid risk than a day trip in a van which is allowed.
Can covid be spread through shit? Probably, most viruses can - Scot Gov is planning to do some sewage treatment works monitoring to see if they can find covid hot spots that way. Are hygiene facilities in a typical van as good as you'd hope to stop disease spread - mostly not. Are people out overnight more likely to go to a local shop for a pint of milk, etc - probably.
So yes I'm sure there can be responsible, covid-safe van-camping, just like there can be responsible covid-safe civilised pub goers - but there can also be other extremes.
I'm not suggesting you shouldn't be able to get back to cluttering up the roadside fairly soon, but given this is a "bonus" early progress I'm not sure we need to go from 0-100% all at once. Let's give those rural areas a bit of a chance to prepare for the onslaught. And councils less of an excuse for being "taken by surprise" if there are poor facilities open for toilets, bins etc.
Personally I can’t fathom the mindset of someone who, being told they can go out and play 2 weeks early, proceeds to piss and moan that they’re not getting to do something else for 2 weeks.
Spot on!
Yeah to be honest I sort of agree just can understand if no one listens to this little bit about overnights.
Callanders preparation are massive billboards on the way in saying "PROTECT OUR VILLAGE"
just feels the wrong way to go about it to me
I may venture to my regular preCOVID trails at Mugdock, on the basis that a lot of the crowds who have been going there may go north for a change of scenery….
@iainc mugdock seems to be getting quieter anyway. it's busy round the visitors centre and Dumbrock Loch, but the trails themselves are not too bad.
The WHW of course is a bit busier than normal. I'd expect that to be busier if folk can travel further now.
pretty quiet in the now light till 8:30 evenings! 🙂
Good to know, thanks Nik
Personally I can’t fathom the mindset of someone who, being told they can go out and play 2 weeks early, proceeds to piss and moan that they’re not getting to do something else for 2 weeks.
I don't think it's pissing and moaning to be concerned that excerising our outdoor access rights (e.g. walking alone or responsible wild camping) is currently illegal without explanation or logical reason, but perhaps that's just me.
without explanation or logical reason,
Have you been asleep for the last year? 🤔
Does someone have a link to a summary of the restrictions by Tier for Scotland?
The arseholes have started early
Honestly, if I never see the Pentlands again!
I can't wait for the Pentlands to quieten down. I'll be avoiding the Tweed as it will be rammed.
I don’t think it’s pissing and moaning to be concerned that excerising our outdoor access rights (e.g. walking alone or responsible wild camping) is currently illegal without explanation or logical reason, but perhaps that’s just me.
I completely agree on "walking alone" but I am currently working on the assumption that that anomaly is a "summarising in 2 bullet points" issue and won't be in the legislation when its published. The point about "restriction on your access rights for responsible wild camping" is not what the debate above is about because there are NO access rights for motorised vehicles.
I’m taking it as notice that I have two weeks use of Highland Region before the hordes of trolley lickers arrive
Just back from a few days in the far North. Hardly a car or van to be seen on the NC500. It just seemed like too good an opportunity to miss!
Well the islands have the right idea - "broken" big ferry..? 😉
Makes my efforts at Dalwhinnie last week look a bit pedestrian.
It still feels like we are a long way off from relatives south of the border being allowed to travel up and stay with us. That is a shame.
aren't the big ferries usually broken when they need them the most?
I don't understand CalMac - are the regular issues poor management, poor maintenance or lack of funds?
I'd be interested to know how Calmac reliability compares to similar other ferries in say Norway or Canada.
aren’t the big ferries usually broken when they need them the most?
Like your central heating only breaks down in the winter?
ScotGov have been fighting back on the option of using the fast boat from the Orkney run to help with route resilience. I think it's still there as a future contingency option while the Western Islanders have been pushing for trials etc so it can be quickly brought into use.
CalMac COVID restrictions means that some ferries are only running 25% of passenger capacity and some routes are already fully booked for May so regardless of whether some of the islands open up or not, there's simply limited means of getting to them.
Big signs going up along Peebles High Street this morning reminding people to observe social distancing and public health advice. And the chip shop on the high street was getting a massive truck load of pre-peeled spuds delivered. I wonder what all this can mean?
And the chip shop on the high street was getting a massive truck load of pre-peeled spuds delivered. I wonder what all this can mean?
They've finally broken Maggie's 1926 vintage tatty peeler? 'tis a shame as it was a family heirloom
Meanwhile the other chippy will always be closing as you turn up post ride.
Thats cos I call them and warn them Steven...
I'd come round and raid your fridge but I don't fancy cat food.
hels
Free MemberBig signs going up along Peebles High Street this morning reminding people to observe social distancing and public health advice. And the chip shop on the high street was getting a massive truck load of pre-peeled spuds delivered. I wonder what all this can mean?
Imma come down tomorrow, park like a **** and lick everything.
From the SCA (Scottish Canoe Association) today:-
Travel: From Friday, some travel restrictions will be relaxed to allow travel across Scotland for the purposes of meeting outdoors with friends and family. This will allow travel for informal physical activity, but not for organised sport. Travel restrictions for wider purposes - including organised sport, leisure, shopping, visiting hospitality premises or staying in tourist accommodation - will remain until 26 April, as originally planned, when all travel restrictions within Scotland will be lifted.
Outdoor gatherings: Up to 6 adults from 6 households can meet outside. The exemption for groups of up to 15 adults taking part in organised outdoor sport remains.
The accelerated easing of travel restrictions on Friday 16 April is aimed at improving the mental health of the nation by encouraging more people to see small groups of family and friends in an informal outdoor setting. Travel for organised sport and physical activity will still be able to resume as originally planned on Monday 26 April. Please note this is consistent with Scottish Government's phased approach to the easing of lockdown restrictions.
I may have lost it further up the thread but certainly they seem to understanding tomorrow's easing not having any change to going out to play if you play is organised or to go to a shop- it's only for social meets outside, not the sport.
If so, not very well communicated as it passed me by. Been a bit busy mind.
I may have lost it further up the thread but certainly they seem to understanding tomorrow’s easing not having any change to going out to play if you play is organised or to go to a shop- it’s only for social meets outside, not the sport.
If so, not very well communicated as it passed me by. Been a bit busy mind.
Yep - I think it was @poly that highlighted it. Of course, what if I travel the breadth of the LA to see a friend and we both decide to ride/walk/paddle etc? The guidance is now so full of holes that it escapes logic (and that's without starting to question the relative risk of heading into the hills on your own vs sitting in someone else's garden).
On the positive side, it might help folk realise why laws take so long to introduce. Consultation, white papers, committees etc are all necessary phases so that we don't always end up with hastily-written and ill conceived legislation that doesn't even make sense.
The guidance is now so full of holes that it escapes logic (and that’s without starting to question the relative risk of heading into the hills on your own vs sitting in someone else’s garden).
This.
Convert, that statement from SCA is consistent with the approach all other sports are taking, ie. SportScotland have told them. But the restriction is for ORGANISED sport (the legislation defines organised but think - club activities, events, stuff with a formal governing body over seeing it).
So @scotroutes, not only can you go and meet a friend in your own LA you could pop down and meet me, and TJ and all of us ride together on an informal ride.
I haven’t found the legislation yet which I assume means it’s not published yet which is pretty crap given there’s so much ambiguity. It’s just as well Police Scotland are taking a light touch approach as I imagine some defence lawyers would have fun with people not possibly being able to know the details of the law.
I haven’t found the legislation yet which I assume means it’s not published yet which is pretty crap given there’s so much ambiguity.
That's been another issue. It's been so hard to find, it's piece-meal, and isn't being updated anywhere near quickly enough. As above, it's hard during a pandemic so I'm not really having a go at anyone but, jeez, it's making it difficult to even try to stay within the law (especially as the guidance has so many ambiguities).
All the rural hotspots are gearing up for tomorrows onslaught so I reckon the majority are seeing this as "brakes off".
TBH this short spell seems a bodge ruleswise but I think that's more excusable/tolerable considering it's literally a 10 day acceleration rather than a policy pillar. If the choice was "let's relax some stuff early but maybe it's a bit of a mess" and "let's just stick to the plan and that way it'll be better organised" I know which one I'd choose.
But "you may travel to exercise in a group but not to exercise alone" is something I'm going to ignore for sure, for these 10 days. And then it stops being an issue in the mainland once we all go tier 3.
I can see the dilemma with laying out exactly what the rules will be on future dates is that it encourages people to start cutting corners early, we've seen that already... "Well if it's OK in a week then I might as well do it today". But right now it feels like it's gone too far the other way and it's hard to plan without a really clear "on this day, it's X, on this day it's Y".
Planning trips outside of the local area again did make me look at the vehicle sharing rules... I didn't realise that they're exactly the same all the way from level 4 to 0- "Avoid car sharing with people outside extended household wherever possible". PLanning a short drive to ride with a mate on sunday and it's no hardship to both drive, but, I'd kind of assumed that was a higher tier thing not a universal.
scotroutes
That’s been another issue. It’s been so hard to find, it’s piece-meal, and isn’t being updated anywhere near quickly enough.
It's usually through these they do it (go on to page 2 for the original SSI that all the amendments relate to ), and when I've been looking it's generally updated the main document on the day or there abouts. Pretty sure it's usually updated on the day or the day after things come into effect. Haven't looked at every amendment every time though.
https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ssi/2021/186/contents/made
That one seems to be the latest amendment still to be applied. I thought there'd be a bit more to it mind, unless there's something else to get added tomorrow?
Northwind
But “you may travel to exercise in a group but not to exercise alone” i
where does it say that?
seosamh77
Full Memberwhere does it say that?
https://www.gov.scot/publications/coronavirus-covid-19-guidance-on-travel-and-transport/#exceptions
> Meeting others (in groups of up to 6 adults from 6 households) socially outdoors, for recreation or exercise. Under 12s do not count towards the number of people meeting or households.
It's not well worded IMO but it is definitely "meeting others" and is the only exception for adults to exercise.
Well those are really just relevant to gatherings.
i think there must be an amendment that will go through tomorrow, because if they are lifting travel restrictions they'll need to repeal these 2 sections.
PART 4
Restrictions on movementRestrictions on leaving Level 4 area
14.—(1) A person who lives in a Level 4 area must not leave or remain away from that area.
(2) But a person who lives in a Level 4 area may leave the area in order to travel to another part of the same area.]Restrictions on entering Level 4 area
15.—(1) A person who does not live in a Level 4 area must not enter or remain in that area.
(2) But a person who does not live in a Level 4 area may travel through it in order to reach a place outwith the area.
Which will allow exercise anywhere alone. That's the only thing restricting it as far as I can see. And well, they are lifting travel restrictions tomorrow eh...
Laws really just tend to tell you what you can't do, not what you can do, unless there's some ambiguity, hence the exceptions for leaving your area being spelled out.
Actually it is a bit stupid if there aren't any further repeals tbh. now I think about it. Youse might have a point. as if they aren't amending or repealing those 2 sections above, they should be spelling out a lot more in the exceptions.
