I have to say that he sounds like a liability to the democrats now - it's not a good look and marginally worrisome thinking he's "in control" (he probably isn't but you know what I mean).
Thoughts?
Go. Obviously.
Many of us will recognise “stubborn old person in denial” syndrome.
Listened to The rest is Politics US and News Agents USA, both reckon he will go, but no one seems to know how to do it and who to replace him with.
Its like the audience member stating "are you two the best we've got?"
I can't help thinking that this is a question that should have been asked with 4 years to go, not with 4 months to go.
Good man in danger of destroying his legacy....oh and letting in a man that could do untold damage to the world.
I can’t help thinking that this is a question that should have been asked with 4 years to go, not with 4 months to go.
Indeed. He had two jobs four years ago - reintroduce grown up government and foster an environment in which a protégé would flourish ready for '24.
Looking more like a liability with every passing day. Time to go.
Its a pretty sorry state of affairs.
Democrats are damned if you do, damned if you don't. If Biden stays Trump wins, its a near certainty.
If Biden goes, who will replace him? Kamala Harris vs Trump doesn't look like a better bet and it doesn't look like there are any better options.
It’s incredible to think Trump and Biden are the best that America has as leaders.
It’s incredible to think Trump and Biden are the best that America has as leaders.
I think the word you're looking for is maybe "sad"
Absolutely go.
There is no way that anyone at that age should be exposed to the pressures and demands of that role.
Added to the obvious decline it is an absolute no brainer.
Should there be age limits on all public offices? I would argue that there should and it should be set at about 70ish
I remember when my father-in-law was in the early stages of dementia before he was officially diagnosed. We were all telling him he shouldn't drive his car because he was going to kill someone and he was in complete denial. Biden is that but scaled up to being in charge of the world's largest military and nuclear arsenal. He should go obviously, I've being saying it for months.
Sadly I think he should go.
As I've said on previous threads and others have said on here, if this is really the best America has to offer then it is a really sorry state of affairs.
The United States has a population approaching 350 million, it claims to be one of the greatest, if not the greatest, democracy in the world. And it has some of the most capable expertise in the world, in every area of human activity.
If they are really scratching their heads trying to think who should replace a president who is clearly no longer up to the job then that suggests a remarkable failure of their democratic process. The choice should be almost infinite.
Can’t let Trump in.
I fear that it might be too late. If it's this diminished Biden or a.n.other, Trump is going to win this. Not the popular vote as that is irrelevant - but in the 6 marginal states that matter the damage is now done.
They should swap the running order... keep Biden as running mate for Harris. She's the only one that can step into the breach at short notice while subduing any claims of chaos or panic. Biden's experience still valuable, but if you can't imagine your president being capable in four years time, voters will stay at home rather than have their vote support the mess that could all become.
I fear Trump will win the election and that will largely be the fault of the Democrats in not addressing this earlier. I think they will drop Biden but only after he's clung on for as long as possible. Any replacement will be seen as too last minute, too desperate by the electorate.
Biden sees it as his life's mission to defeat Trump, he sees it as his duty, I genuinely think that's where his head is at and that's why he's going to be hugely reluctant to pass the batton and giving him a way to duck out with dignity is going be a really tough needle to thread.
It's massively unfair, he's actually lead a genuinely effective and competent administration in very challenging circumstances, he's earned a 2nd term.
But... it has to happen, he's clearly in rapid decline, he's not the man he was even a year ago, he has a great team around him but that's just not enough and him staying almost guarantees the final ascension of American Fascism (and I do not use that term lightly).
Crap situation all round.
Limited knowledge on US politics, but it appears Trump wants him to stay so it's probably best that he gets replaced by someone younger and sharper.
Go
I can’t help thinking that this is a question that should have been asked with 4 years to go, not with 4 months to go.
Indeed. He had two jobs four years ago – reintroduce grown up government and foster an environment in which a protégé would flourish ready for ’24.
This sums it all up for me...the democrats should have been planning his replacement from day 1 of his presidency! Damned if they do, damned if they don't though: he should go but changing candidate this close to the election looks terrible too. Massive failing by the democrats
Whether he's up to the job or not (& I think he's not) the narrative is there now and every single misstep he does will be amplified
He needs to be gone now, but theres huge issues with that, legally the campaign funds he's raised cannot go to anyone else, except Harris & Republican lawmakers are already preparing appeals should to block her or anyone else getting them. A new candidate , other than Harris, would need to get the massive campaign team in place, book speaking venues etc etc in a few weeks.
Realistically Harris is the most likely replacement but shes not that popular and the Harris birther conspiracy theories are already out there & already being mentioned by Trump: very good wired podcast about them here:
https://pod.link/1516843565/episode/210b88c73fa5f17bafa21d5ee46edb3b
all that said in some polls shes beating Trump! and with Biden out of the way and a younger candidate on offer all of a sudden the focus would very quickly switch to Trumps declining mental state and some of the very senior moments he's been having that are completely overshadowed by Biden
Another option and probably a long odds bet that might get you a good return is President Michelle Obama....
4 years ago I put a small bet on AOC for 2024 US president. She could be so good. Absolutely no chance of that happening now. What a mess.
Clooney should put his money where his mouth is and stand for election.
Many of us will recognise “stubborn old person in denial” syndrome.
Biden or Trump?
FLOTUS appears to be working him from the back, as per Nancy and Ron a few years ago. For the good of his party, country and the free world it's obvious he has to go, and soon, to allow a younger, more capable, replacement to be selected to debate / defeat Trump.
It's amazing if people vote for "The President" and not the party they want to lead the country. Imagine being American and having to choose, surely you'd go by the politics of the Democrats and just hope Biden gets replaced sometime into his tenure.
4 years ago I put a small bet on AOC for 2024 US president. She could be so good. Absolutely no chance of that happening now.
Much like the UK Labour party preferred the tories to Corbyn, the democrats would rather Trump be president than AOC.
4 years ago I put a small bet on AOC for 2024 US president. She could be so good. Absolutely no chance of that happening now.
Much like the UK Labour party preferred the tories to Corbyn, the democrats would rather Trump be president than AOC.
was never a chance, average American voter (not to mention their media) is so far to the right of AOC they cant even see her
Mixing up Zelensky with Putin? Short of actually pissing himself on stage in front of the press, I'm struggling to think of a worse scenario for him.
I have a £50 bet on Newsom to be next President, placed after the debate. Might be a nice little earner.
Biden needs to go.
Problem is Harris is not very popular and the funding they have raised so far can only be spent on Biden and Harris.
Looks like Project 2025 is incoming.
Keep Biden
Assassinate Trump
Recent Supreme Court ruling on presidential immunity comes in handy here. I'm sure it could be dressed up as an 'official act'.
I just don't think that there is any way that a new candidate outperforms Biden electorally. Once you get past a certain point in the electoral cycle, the Democrat politicians and funders/supporters would have been better off keeping their misgivings to themselves.
He could be semi-comatose and still be a better option for the US and the world than Trump.
Biden should go but before he does he should “accidently” approve the assassination of Putin & his crew.
Go out with a bang. A big one.
given his latest gaff which world leader do you think will be the accidental recepient of this?
Biden has to go. His job from Day 1 should have been to create a platform for a new generation of Democratic leaders, and Harris in particular, to compete and win against a chaotic and corrupt Republican Party. He has totally failed to do that. Harris wasn't a great performer as VP but he also has not given her room to grow.
Biden has persevered through personal tragedy (his wife and child being killed, another son dying of cancer, another son in addiction and crime) by throwing himself ever harder into work. And so far it has paid off. But he cannot and should not pull this last trick off.
There is still time for the Dems to nominate an ass-kicking, public-connecting candidate at the convention.
Run with Harris and Gavin Newsom.
I like them individually but 2 Californians? No way.
Michelle Obama would be a terrible idea. She has never been elected and has no platform. She is very smart but she's not going to win over anyone that's not already a D. And it would be better for US politics to move away from political dynasties...Kennedy, Bush, Clinton, Obama...
Feels like the choice is between two poor options.
- He stays in post and loses (definitely)
- Messy replacement process and new candidate has a very slim chance of taking it...
The constant commentary about means they really have to go with 2, soon, and then really nail trump's mental decline.
Lots of respect for Biden, but I fear he's at a point that he's no longer able to make a coherent decision.
There is the 25th amendment (was discussed while trump was president) don't know if that's in discussion for Biden.
https://www.history.com/news/presidents-ill-25-amendment
The problem is not so much Biden, but the fact that Harris is a dud electorally. It's a fundamentally flawed ticket, and Biden should have had the sense, as a man in his 80s, to advance a vp who could not just step in if he was incapacitated during his term, but be high-profile enough to build support throughout that period.
Biden is a good man who is old and frail. Trump is an old, frail, rapist felon who tried to overthrow the government, was bezzie mates with the most high profile sexual abuser in recent history, is facing charges under the espionage act, and has promised a presidency of revenge against his enemies.
I’m pretty disappointed in the display of arrogance and egotism from Joe Biden and his close advisers.
They’re willing to risk the chaos of a Trump win because they refuse to do the right thing and have him step aside.
Many would be Democrat voters will abstain if Biden is on the ticket, allowing Trump to win.
Piss poor politics.
It’s amazing if people vote for “The President” and not the party they want to lead the country. Imagine being American and having to choose, surely you’d go by the politics of the Democrats and just hope Biden gets replaced sometime into his tenure.
The whole point of having separation of powers and separate elections for the executive is to ensure that it is not just an extension of the dominant parliamentary party.
There was originally no need for a President to even be a member of a party and IIRC there was an early tradition of the runner up in the Presidential election being appointed as VP by the victor. Admittedly those are probably obsolete and unrecoverable now
If Biden was my elderly neighbour I wouldn't ask him to look after my cats . I would think it was too much to ask an elderly neighbour.
