Forum menu
I was in my local Halfrauds today & they had Bike Hut carbon seatposts in the clearance bin for £15, are they any good or a waste of £15? They also had oversize ally bars for £5. Any comments would be appreciated. Cheers.
How bad can they be for £15? Maybe not suitable for a DH bike or a lot of abuse, but should be ok- a lot of the Bikehut stuff is ok kit
I saw them too, (in halfrauds, Northampton)
THey can't be that bad
IIRC Halfords carbons seatposts only have a carbon wrap and and ally core.
How bad could a broken carbon fibre seat post be? How graphic do you want an answer!?
More than likely it's made in the same factory as a whole load of other branded ones. At £15 it's got to be worth a punt if you're in the market for a post
if you asked the question could you ever trust it?
They're made by Tioga... Should do the job just fine.
Cheers for your thoughts fellas. Northwind, appreciate that, if they are Tioga then I'll give one a go
If these are the normally £40 inline double bolt clamp seatposts (I have two of these on my bikes) they are full carbon, not carbon wrap. I have one on an Orange 5 and one a Kona Kula hardtail and they are SUPERB! 410mm long, and don't give me a minutes trouble. Absolute bargain if they're now selling them at £15! I know Decathlon sell a single bolt layback carbon post for £22 which is carbon wrap but the inline Haflords are ace. The one on my Orange 5 is over three years old and that bike is ridden in the Peak District at least once a week. If they did them in various diameters rather than just 27.2mm, I'd have them on all of my bikes.
Yep got one at £15 couple of weeks back. Full carbon post actually quite nice - factor in some gritty paste as mine slipped like buggery.
They where inline double bolt seat clamp, but 350mm post iirc. Are there any issues with using one of these with a shim?
Tell me, what's wrong with carbon wrap, is it a bad idea, heavier, more breakable, what?
Genuine Q
Most carbon wrap is just for cosmetic reasons so really just adds weight
What Fuzzy said - might as well just go for a alu post.........wish I'd have known aboiut these full carbon halfords posts 4 weeks ago before stumping up for an Easton
Look closely end on and you can see a wire core.
crikey thats a bargain reggiegasket..
Does the Halfords one look like this?
[img] 
[/img]
Thats an Outland one from ebay, choice of diameters but its £30
Oooh Carbon Seatposts... Under £20!???
Soo... Which one is the best, the PBK or HellFruads?
I realise they are going to way a fair bit, the PBK one is apparently the same weight as a EA30 seatpost, its the vibration obsorbtion capabilities that I'm interested in.
Which one's better?
alloy/carbon composites are actualy quite strong, but its like steel bikes, a cheep bike shaped object is rubbish, an expensive one can be better than most of the alternatives.
As for the scaremongering horror stories about carbon posts snapping, from experience testing carbon hockey sticks to destruction, i'd guess the carbon ones goign to give more warning and wont "snap" they usaly just leave one end trailing fromt he other when the resin fails and the carbon remains intact holding the 2 together.
That PBK one is cheap for the weight.
Halfords kit is often good for the money. I had one of those posts for a year or so and eventually changed it for one of theose specialized pave ones. It was fine. it didn't snap. i used it on a roadrat and it semmed quite comfortable.
which halfords are they for sale in?
They are not for sale in my local Halfords! They had Riser bars for sale for £17.99 (aluminium) and seat posts for £15 (aluminiumm). 😥
Nor could I find the £20 shock pump!
Well i bought another one after seeing this thread and it stayed in a box of spares until earlier this month, and its snapped after the third ride! Snapped half way up the exposed bit too, nowhere near the clamp.