[Closed] Croix De Fer alternatives . ?

Bike has a Cycra Guard, flatter and wider than a Crud front so better for road bikes tighter clearance.
First bought them for the fatbikes as wider too; [url= http://www.cycraguard.co.uk/front ]CycraGuard MTB front[/url]

Vital Spark lives up in the middle of that ride and rides here too so be up for a bit of this roughstuff on his crosser!
loads of this stuff around East Lothian 🙂

Vital Spark lives up in the middle of that ride and rides here too so be up for a bit of this roughstuff on his crosser!
loads of this stuff around East Lothian

I'd say Singular Peregrine, but I would as I've had one for years.
Other options could be: Soma Double Cross Disc and/or Surly Straggler. A Rivendell might be an option, but I don't think they do a disc frame.

That Transition is *very* tempting - it's the same F&F as the Traitor Crusade, so I guess it could appear here as either? In a similar vein, I've read that the Singular Kite may well move to discs too for it's next iteration, but you'd need to weigh up the availability/non-availability of rack / guard mountings on them both I'd guess.

Another vote for the pinnacle arkose, I tested it back to back with a Croix de fer and much preferred it.

if it was a stock croix then I am not surprised as it is a different beast with decent wheels on it...

Well said jameso. And a big thanks to you also for all the advice which helped me decide, even though I didn't go for the Arkose in the end !

^ no probs ianc, as long as people are happy with their choices all's good. I still ride my Equilibrium.. : )

Can you stop wasting time on here, James, and design a SS version of the [url= http://www.evanscycles.com/products/pinnacle/ramin-one-2014-mountain-bike-ec055206 ]Ramin One[/url], please 8)

....£350-ish price tag would be just super.

Got it..
I'd like to, do more SS bikes as well as stop wasting time on here. There are plans and sample SS bikes ordered etc. Maybe not a Ramin yet but if the tensioner works, I'd like one so that's usually enough to get it in the range (to start with). But £350? ..Don't ask for much. V brakes right?

Ok, back to CX bikes.

But £350?

Ok. £375 😀

Right. Back to CX bikes.

The OE wheels are pretty similar on both, overall weight and rim spec. 470-480g rims I think? Some prefer alu+carbon, some prefer steel, good to have a choice )

yes but the overall bike weight will be more because of the steel/alu difference, and when a bike gets towards 26lbs it starts to feel a bit too heavy, as the stock croix does.

Interesting as my 2014 Croix is about 3lbs heavier than the 07 Jake the snake it replaced, but has a few extra gears out back. Feels heavier putting on the roof, but haven't noticed it on road or trails.

I am not saying it is too heavy - but whenever you see someone complain about a croix it is always because of weight.

My wheels aren't stupid light at 1610g with 32 spokes, but the whole bike is 22.5lbs with pedals which feels nice, and is only 2lbs more than my equilibrium which doesn't have disks.

TG, your CdF is lighter than my winter-kitted Equilibrium ) good work.

I ride a Cotic X with a build somewhere between the Croix and its big brother, the Equilibrium disc (105 except for Tiagra shifters and 11-32 cassette, XT hubs, GP 4 Season tyres, EA50 finishing kit, BB5s).

Although it's clearly a different bike from the Croix, the concept and my style of use are the same.

It's one bike for everything. I do most of my miles on it: commuting, shopping, kids on the back, occasional longer road rides. Brilliant. 🙂

I should want a CDF but can't help feeling its a bit sort of dull..sorry. Maybe if it came in a different colour than the commuter black or had a different group set I could get juiced about it but even with a custom build it could still do with more clearance.

That said there isn't too many alternatives. The Merida four cross looks better in the flesh than pics online would suggest, flat top tube, traditional external headset and cables, matched with good kit, 105, nova tech hubs etc seems pretty good.

It's not steel but the Norco threshold a1 looks good

I should want a CDF but can't help feeling its a bit sort of dull..sorry. Maybe if it came in a different colour than the commuter black

The CdF is silver.

[img] [/img]

You knew what I meant.

Indeed, and it's silver.

coastkid - I've also got a blue 2013 CdF.

What's the rear mudguard, is it also a Cyrca? I've currently borrowed the one I put on my old Kona Fire Mountain (1992) but it's a little short!

Prob way OT, but i'm rocking this frankenbike for mile munching

Surly LHT with a few mods 😉

[img] [/img]

[img] [/img]

Built like a tank & rides ace everywhere!
As you were....

Surly straggler is the new Disk braked version of their cross bike...

Which is a tenuous enough link for me to post a pic of my Disk trucker on the wetter than wet granite trail today

[img] [/img]

Jamie - Member
Indeed, and it's silver.
POSTED 1 HOUR AGO #

Was really worth posting a quote and a picture to prove your a pedantic gobshite? Your life..I mean your actual life must be very dull.

I've just brought a Croix de Fer 931 after getting a PPI payout.
It's very nice

More - Kona Sutra, Specialized AWOL, Kinesis Tripster?

Preferred the arkose geometry, but I am a bit of a weird shape-tall, long arms, long legs short torso. Brakes were better on the arkose were better. Didn't notice the genesis weight really. Heart said genesis, but the arkose just rode better for me.

Was really worth posting a quote and a picture to prove your a pedantic gobshite? Your life..I mean your actual life must be very dull.

It's 30 seconds of my life I will never see again 🙁

jerrys - Member
coastkid - I've also got a blue 2013 CdF.

What's the rear mudguard, is it also a Cyrca? I've currently borrowed the one I put on my old Kona Fire Mountain (1992) but it's a little short!

Rear guard is a Zefal road rear; [url= http://www.wiggle.co.uk/zefal-swan-road-rear-mudguard/ ]Zefal Road Rear Guard[/url]

Clean and dry ass after 50 miles with a lot of puddles! 🙂

Rear guard is a Zefal road rear; Zefal Road Rear Guard

I use one of those. Really good, bit of a squeeze when using the saddle bag/rear light, but does all fit.

If you don't already have a front mudguard, and just want to occasionally chuck one on the downtube, the swan/croozer pack is very good value at £15:

http://www.amazon.co.uk/Zefal-Swan-Croozer-Clip-On-Guard/dp/B005J528IS

Jamie - croozer and swan here too - very effective and much better off road than the SKS p45's 🙂

Jamie - croozer and swan here too - very effective and much better off road than the SKS p45's

Yup. Also found they rattle less than regular road guards, and much quicker to fit/remove.

It does mean my seat post is full up with the Swan and Topeak saddle pack on it, so have to mount the Lunar R2 on the seat stays.

coastkid - re getting ride sorted, have sent you a FB request through Sanny, cheers

here's my CdF. Took it for a spin around salisbury yesterday. The roads were fine, however off road was a bit challenging!

[img] [/img]

[img] [/img]

a bit muddy looking, even with cx tyres 🙂

I ended plumping for a 2014 Cdf as I got it at a ridiculously good price 😉 , Anyhoo I picked it up in Herfordshire and road 55 miles into and through London . First impressions were that It's really comfy despite the standard Madison prime seat . The big tyres mean thats It's not a chore to ride on pot hole strewn roads , I also took it out tonight locally through easy singletrack trails and It was a hoot with full on clipped in broadsiding. 😀
Obviously It's heavier than my road bike but It seems like it will be way comfier over longer runs.

Was really worth posting a quote and a picture to prove your a pedantic gobshite? Your life..I mean your actual life must be very dull.

In your first sentence, you need an "it" in there somewhere at the start to make it make sense, and at the end of the first sentence it is "you're" not "your".

First impressions were that It's really comfy despite the standard Madison prime seat

The Prime is supposed to be a roady version of the Charge Spoon, so should be fairly comfy. I bought one as I couldn't find a Spoon in the colour I wanted, with the intention being to swap when I found a Spoon So far, no complaints, so going to keep using it.

@Jamie , your probably right about the seat . I have Madison Fluxs on my mtb which are very spoon like . I thought about getting a Selle Regal but that is probably more for looks than comfort.
What kind of tyres are folks using on there CX bikes , the contis which came with the bike are fine and quick on the road and slidy and fun in the mud.
[img] [/img]

I run [url= http://www.chainreactioncycles.com/schwalbe-smart-sam-sport-cross-bike-tyre-wire/rp-prod106775 ]Schwalbe Smart Sams[/url], as they were cheap and seemed ok.

Seriously considering something like this. Love my genesis skyline but need gears. Not getting on as well as expected with the disco.
If the croix had a tapered headtube so could take a full carbon fork to bring the weight down but a pound it would tick all the boxes

If the croix had a tapered headtube so could take a full carbon fork to bring the weight down but a pound it would tick all the boxes

[url= http://www.evanscycles.com/products/pinnacle/arkose-three-2014-cyclocross-bike-ec054866 ]Pinnacle Arkose[/url] is a similar beast.

Just ally with a tapered full carbon fork.

Not a cx bike but the shand stoater (plus in this pic but I think I could live with the regular one too) looks lovely - love it in this colour

[img] [/img]