One of those 'please recommend me a bike' threads

Bike Forum

One of those 'please recommend me a bike' threads

24 posts & 18 voices | Started 6 months ago by geetee1972 | Latest reply from jamiec360

Tags:

No tags yet.

geetee1972 - Member

Hi all,

I had a little crash recently. Nothing major, just broke my clavicle and fractured a few vertibrae. I live to ride again.

However it's been strongly recommended that I give up riding a hard tail. I have a Ragley Titanium (of which I have previously waxed lyrical about on here) that I bought in January. It's now for sale, but what I need, other than offers for the Ragges, is suggestions for a light weight, 4" travel slacked out trail bike.

The Orange ST4 is one choice. What would be others?

Posted 6 months ago #
Gotama - Member

Transition Bandit

Posted 6 months ago #
freeridenick - Member

Northern Monkeys are dangerous

What about one of those new ragleys 10-4 ? with 4inch out the back
transition double - would be my weapon of choice when I get to old for my Kobe!

Posted 6 months ago #
wors - Member

what size is the ti?

I'd say st4

Posted 6 months ago #
ti_pin_man - Member

This is a bike forum? No way?

But seriously I don't suppose you'll get many answers on a mountain bike question lol.

My first answer is any FS but then I got thinking and wondered how the logic works and who exactly said no hardtail? Most docs wouldn't know the difference or understand the difference unless they actually rode mtb's and understand the difference. I am asking because it if it was me I would push back and get a few more opinions from other professionals who know their cycling . Maybe your guy does. Sorry if he does .

Sorry mate, just seems an odd thing. They could be right just I would double or triple check. Maybe you already did?

Posted 6 months ago #
sambob - Member

How about a custom frame from 18 bikes? That'd give you geometry you want, as well as being completely unique. Or swap my FSR XC frame for your Ragley, that'd work too...

Posted 6 months ago #
Northwind - Member

Was very underwhelmed with the ST4 myself, couldn't see much point to it compared to the Five- doesn't climb much better, but deals with rough stuff much worse. But ymmv.

Blur 4X? Not light...

Posted 6 months ago #
honourablegeorge - Member

ti_pin_man - Member
This is a bike forum? No way?

But seriously I don't suppose you'll get many answers on a mountain bike question lol.

My first answer is any FS but then I got thinking and wondered how the logic works and who exactly said no hardtail? Most docs wouldn't know the difference or understand the difference unless they actually rode mtb'd and understand the difference. I am asking because it seems a bit extreme for a broken collar bone to recommend a type of bike? And if it was me I would push back and stick with it until I got more body of opinion from proffessionals who know their cycling .

Sorry mate, just seems an odd thing.

"fractured vertebrae" is probably the clue you're looking for here.

Posted 6 months ago #
z1ppy - Member

Pivot Mach 4 or the slacker M4X
2012 Scott Spark
Giant TranceX

Posted 6 months ago #
headfirst - Member

"fractured vertebrae" is probably the clue you're looking for here.

Indeed, as someone who has done the same, it wasn't long after I was back on the bike that I decided FS was the way to go, as my back was starting to ache like buggery well before my legs started to get tired on the hardtail. The full suss brought pleasure back to my rides, finishing with a smile on my face again rather than a grimace.

I've got a Spesh Stumpy FSR for what it's worth.

Posted 6 months ago #
geetee1972 - Member

All good points, well made and gratefully received. It's a bit of a convoluted explanation but I've a very good friend who is a bike rider and radiographer. He managed to look at my scans and was the one suggesting that the hardtail 'might' not be such a good idea. He was very keen to underline the word 'might' and said I should try it and see. I've also had advice from an osteopath who said that the jarring and vibration of a hardtail could cause cumulative damage that gives me problems later in life. None of this is certain, it's all speculative, but given that i've got a few years left in me and a young family I feel more inclined to circumspection rather than circumcision (metaphorically speaking). Oh and a new bike opportunity should never be sniffed at.

Ragley Ti is 16" BTW. Totally unmarked and comes with receipts etc.

Posted 6 months ago #
5lab - Member

banshee wildcard is slack long, low and short travel

Posted 6 months ago #
metalheart - Member

There's the Mythic/Banshee Spitfire.

It's plenty slack, although a little longer in the bounce I think.

Never tried one but it seemed well received on mtbr, no?

Posted 6 months ago #
sambob - Member

Epic Evo is another possibility, very nice bike.

Posted 6 months ago #
davidtaylforth - Member

One of these: http://www.gtbicycles.com/gbr/2012/bikes/mountain/enduro/2012-distortion-2-0

Posted 6 months ago #
kilo - Member

Get a Nicolai - didn't read the whole thread but some bloke was raving about them on here yesterday

Posted 6 months ago #
geetee1972 - Member

Get a Nicolai - didn't read the whole thread but some bloke was raving about them on here yesterday

Yeah I just read that thread and it's a bit of a shame really. Doesn't change my opinion but I can see where both sides are coming from.

The Nic is on the shortlist.

Posted 6 months ago #
ti_pin_man - Member

Fair do's fella... I was just asking cos medical staff I have had advice from over the years don't really know what mountain biking is and play the safe risk card. Usually over safe lol.

Posted 6 months ago #
geetee1972 - Member

Fair do's fella... I was just asking cos medical staff I have had advice from over the years don't really know what mountain biking is and play the safe risk card. Usually over safe lol.

It's true!

Posted 6 months ago #
richmtb - Member

SC Superlight with 120mm forks?

Or by a Blur LT and just pretend its 4 inch travel!

(I might be a Santa Cruz fanboy though!)

Posted 6 months ago #
Bunnyhop - Member

Get well soon GT.
I have a Turner Flux (not slacked at the mo.) which I love. It's a bit on the very small side for you to try when you're next ooop North.

Posted 6 months ago #
van cough cough - Member

What size is the Ragley Ti?

Posted 6 months ago #
van cough cough - Member

oops 16.. just caught up

Love my Ragley.

Posted 6 months ago #
jamiec360 - Member

Whyte T120 like mine. Good deals on the 2011s if you can still find them. Light and very active with good kit for the money and nice slack head angle but not as short as a stumpy.

Posted 6 months ago #

RSS feed for this topic

Reply

You must log in to post.

Singletrack Mountain Bike Magazine

Bike Forum

One of those 'please recommend me a bike' threads

Reply

Don't miss…

Singletrack

Website & Forums

Exits