Charlie – and you are so much better qualified than me to have an opinion on a piece of music? You fail to understand this

But hey ho – what do I know

You like others on here just like an excuse to jump in and give a good kicking.

So tell me – how are you qualified to call me ignorant?

Well, I may be wrong, but I suspect most people would be offended by being called “gullible and credulous” But maybe I’m just over-sensitive.

I shall henceforce kill this thread with a display of pure GENIUS.

[video]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=noXYiNo5TOo[/video]

[video]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EjAoBKagWQA&feature=related[/video]

[video]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3WHKeFLy1Bo&feature=related[/video]

[video]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y8XVHnNaJOo&feature=related[/video]

TandemJeremy – Member

was ALWAYS going to provoke a negative reaction

you were trolling, whether for attention or just for kicks I dunno. But you WERE trolling.

actually I wasn’t – just typing quicker than I thought and not thinking about how what I typed would be perceived.

And there it is – we started with the Edinburgh Variation, and finish (cross fingers, touch wood) with the Edinburgh Defence, from the original master.

[video]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VU3JrXt_cPk&feature=related[/video]

[video]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wHuXpWSNa-8&feature=related[/video]

[video]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CQHm3LK_6GQ&feature=related[/video]

[video]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6CSiU0j_lFA&feature=related[/video]

Big Time Sensuality is my favourite video ever. (Today.)

[video]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pgk360PZJ7w&feature=related[/video]

[video]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3biZkA-TNvs[/video]

actually I wasn’t – just typing quicker than I thought and not thinking about how what I typed would be perceived.

like i said – been on here too long not know this. Still calling troll. Won’t be admitted as once the edinburgh defence has been committed it cannot be retracted.

Has anyone seen any of the work of Bjork’s partner, Matthew Barney? I endured (in the nicest possible way!) his Cremaster Cycle a few years ago – the only time I’ve ever felt like I’d taken drugs after watching cinema. Much of it went way over (and under) my head; but the experience was fascinating.

[video]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s-V_CtrVj5U[/video]

[video]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gXU8L-YRSNU[/video]

[video]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CHiHZ35TPfM[/video]

DrJ – Member

Well, I may be wrong, but I suspect most people would be offended by being called “gullible and credulous” But maybe I’m just over-sensitive.

Indeed and I apologise for that.

Call me a liar if you want – it was not a troll – its was me unthinkingly saying what I thought. This is not “the edinburgh defense” I have never done that and find the accusations of lying offensive.

[video]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5q1BvSZNbUg[/video]

[video]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EepPNrZoOGw[/video]

I apologise for that.

Charlie – and you are so much better qualified than me to have an opinion on a piece of music?

Perhaps not, but then again I didn’t offer one, but it wasn’t just music about which you opined either, you went on to offer your opinion about art too.

You fail to understand this

But hey ho – what do I know

I fully understand that, I just have trouble reconciling it with

Its only an opinion. A strong one perhaps but its all it is

You like others on here just like an excuse to jump in and give a good kicking.

Not at all, I, perhaps like others are have just had enough about you spouting shite about stuff when you haven’t got a clue. When you speak from an informed or less dogmatic point of view, you’ll find I don’t jump in a give a kicking.

So tell me – how are you qualified to call me ignorant?

Well, I don’t need to be qualified to call you ignorant. However, if you admit to it yourself, like this

But hey ho – what do I know

then I’m only taking your word for it.

This is not “the edinburgh defense” I have never done that and find the accusations of lying offensive.

hmmm i think you have TJ. Are you seriously trying to tell me that you hit the send button without thinking about the effect your words have on people?

This is not “the edinburgh defense” I have never done that and find the accusations of lying offensive.

Then stop lying.

I think this thread just needs to:

before it:

[video]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=da3Xun-yGCQ[/video]

Yup – sometimes – as I did here. Type and click send.

I do not lie. I do not post in seriousness and then later claim it was all a big joke.

I do however post intemperately, impetuously and unthinkingly fairly frequently

Oh well. I’mouddahe.

I do however post intemperately, impetuously and unthinkingly fairly frequently

then i don’t think you can get upset when people kick you about for it.

can you?

Loved her work for ever – Personal faves:

For musical beauty

[video]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2BSMcVRgloY[/video]

for bonkersness:

[video]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U_D6nxAa7rA[/video]

yossarian – Member

“I do however post intemperately, impetuously and unthinkingly fairly frequently “

then i don’t think you can get upset when people kick you about for it.

can you?

Accepted

This is not “the edinburgh defense” I have never done that and find the accusations of lying offensive

You accuse us of lying ALL THE **** TIME and no, it’s not nice at all. Please don’t do it to us in future!

Yeah, and stop lying too

i don’t think TJ is a liar actually, he definitely gets steamed up to the point where he HAS TO KEEP ARGUING TO WIN, but then so do many, many others.

i don’t think TJ is a liar actually, he definitely gets steamed up to the point where he HAS TO KEEP ARGUING TO WIN, but then so do many, many others.

I think a few of us resemble that remark, but there’s a difference between arguing a considered and honestly held case, and banging off some abuse and then trying to prop it up with ex post facto bulldust.

but there’s a difference between arguing a considered and honestly held case, and banging off some abuse and then trying to prop it up with ex post facto bulldust.

of course, but someone who posts intemperately, impetuously and unthinkingly fairly frequently is far, far more likely to find themselves in that position on a regular basis.

of course, but someone who posts intemperately, impetuously and unthinkingly fairly frequently is far, far more likely to find themselves in that position on a regular basis

especially if they just make stuff up

Charlie – you keep saying that. It doesn’t make it true. More consistent negative posting from you

I do not lie, I do not make things up

I will however simply ignore you in future as you are dull and negative all the time.

Charlie – you keep saying that. It doesn’t make it true. More consistent negative posting from you

I do not lie, I do not make things up

What? So now I can’t call you a liar?

This thread needs a random pic..

look, tj, 2 free ones

Any words of wisdom from the massive – I’ve never really like Bjork but the descriptions of the live shows sound amazing. Worth going to for the visuals and other fx?

look, tj, 2 free ones

It’s difficult to get an idea of scale from that picrture. Are they mini pork pies?

What? So now I can’t call you a liar?

If not, I guess what you said earlier is not true.

It’s difficult to get an idea of scale from that picrture. Are they mini pork pies?

possibly just teeny weeny little ones that you can slip on a plate hidden under a lettuce leaf so’s no one will notice, then you pat yourself on the back revelling in your smugness at getting away with some pork pie related fraud

If not, I guess what you said earlier is not true.

The Edinburgh Paradox

Sorry to drag up old thread. Hopefully won’t restart debate!
Saw Biophilia last night. Unadulterated genius!
Fantastic!
~And bonkers!