Viewing 29 posts - 1 through 29 (of 29 total)
  • Who is more in debt, you or the Government?
  • thisisnotaspoon
    Free Member

    To put the governemtns £1001billion debt into perspective, how healthy are you on an international scale.

    The rules (based on the UN’s rules):

    Assets don’t count, a £100,000 morgage on a £200,000 house is a £100,000 debt, nothing more nothing less. A £10,000 credit card and a £200,000 house with no mortgage is still a £10,000 debt.

    Earnings are before tax.

    Borrowing is new debt from the last 12 months, this includes your monthly credit card even if you pay it off on time every month, harsh but thats the rules.

    Debt is your total debt (mortgage + credit card + bak loans etc etc)

    The government is borrowing at 11.5% of GDP and its debt was 71% of GDP.

    You can’t report a surplus only 0 debt.

    1.4% of GDP borrowing and no debt here. The international tagets are 3% and 60%.

    mastiles_fanylion
    Free Member

    42

    Drac
    Full Member

    On a scale to do with anyone else, none of your business.

    j_me
    Free Member

    More than Prince Charles but less than Ireland.

    What’s yours tnas ? You can’t expect people to answer a question like this without being open about it yourself.

    iDave
    Free Member

    you go first OP

    geoffj
    Full Member

    you go first OP

    He did, but the willy waving will stop when he eventually attempts to get on the housing ladder 😆

    thisisnotaspoon
    Free Member

    I already did 1.4% and 0%

    You don’t need to post it up, just puts it in perspective when people lament the government for having essentialy debt of 71% of its earnings, yet loads of people have mortgages at upto 500%

    Drac
    Full Member

    yet loads of people have mortgages at upto 500%

    Really? I doubt that.

    djglover
    Free Member

    Yeah, well over 200% here, was over 400% previously. Risky but it paid off

    j_me
    Free Member

    So Wayne and Waynetta living on 100% sate benefits but no HP widescreen TV’s are sitting pretty on this international scale.

    Not sure if it’s fair to rule out the mortgage asssets. Someone repaying a modest mortgage will in the end have a capital asset on their balance sheet. Where as Ireland…..well it will just have paid off a debt.

    thisisnotaspoon
    Free Member

    5x salary isn’t uncommon.

    footflaps
    Full Member

    0 debt

    Junkyard
    Free Member

    The difference between their debt and mine is I am buying somthing with a re sale value they are borrowing to do the food shopping.
    i dont know why we should compare the two tbh

    thisisnotaspoon
    Free Member

    Government assets aren’t counted, otherwise we’d take credit for north sea oil, and the ability to sell off military kit or privatise services.

    In theory Irelands debt should have bought it an economy.

    In theory your morgage should buy you a house but like the economy it could be worth £0 if prices crash (Ireland) or it falls down (Japan).

    Drac
    Full Member

    5x salary isn’t uncommon.

    But it’s not ‘loads’ though is it.

    j_me
    Free Member

    it could be worth £0 if prices crash (Ireland)or it falls down (Japan).

    Indeed it could, but I’ll take my chances thanks.

    IanMunro
    Free Member

    I’ve got better things to do then look at my last 12 credit card statements to wrk out my borrowing, so the figures would be
    something% of GDP borrowing , and no debt.

    SurroundedByZulus
    Free Member

    0 here too on the basis that nobody in their right mind would give me credit.

    Edukator
    Free Member

    No debt, no borrowing, plenty of assets.

    phil.w
    Free Member

    just puts it in perspective when people lament the government for having essentialy debt of 71% of its earnings, yet loads of people have mortgages at upto 500%

    …err, your comparing apples to oranges. If the government debt is 71% of GDP this is not 71% of earnings.

    The governments earnings are what it takes in tax.

    thisisnotaspoon
    Free Member

    Ok, the country’s debt then.

    You could use all your earnings to pay off debt, but you cant because it needs to be spent on other things.

    The govenrment could have a 100% tax etc………

    neilforrow
    Full Member

    24.3% of GDP / no debt

    ourmaninthenorth
    Full Member

    May I be the first to state that, since no man is an island, it’s highly unlikely he is an autonomous nation state. Accordingly, the rules of governmental debt copmparators don’t apply to me.

    For that reason, I’m out.

    s
    Free Member

    Who cares, its sunny outside if you have not noticed 😉

    Saccades
    Free Member

    50% borrowing and 400% GDP 😉

    I live in ireland – is it all my fault then?

    edit to say, I was at 550% GDP, and I was one of the sensible ones getting a mortgage I thought I could comfortablely afford.

    Torminalis
    Free Member

    The government. Not doing any sums though I would say close to 3%/0% or so. Still skint.

    uplink
    Free Member

    Given that I pretty much buy everything on a credit card and pay it off each month 0% APR & ~1.2% cash back – I reckon about 50% borrowing & 0% debt

    I have a lot more in savings than I ever borrow though, so I’m not really sure your model is fit for purpose

    ac282
    Full Member

    So those saying 0 don’t use credit cards at all?

    For me it would be 100s of %.

    piedidiformaggio
    Free Member

    Size 9 to 10 depending on what shop I buy them in

Viewing 29 posts - 1 through 29 (of 29 total)

The topic ‘Who is more in debt, you or the Government?’ is closed to new replies.