Viewing 40 posts - 1 through 40 (of 173 total)
  • What is wrong with tradesmen?
  • franksinatra
    Full Member

    Why is it so difficult to find decent, reliable tradesmen/women? All they need to do is answer the phone, turn up when they say they will and do a decent job.

    Three weeks in a row I’ve waiting in for a builder/joiner/plumber guy to turn up to look at my bathroom which is needing to be replaced. He is doing some work on another project I am involved in (not at home) and I know he does a good job so I have pretty much said the work is his. He also knows we are getting drawings done for a large extension. All he actually needs to do s turn up and give me a sensible price.

    Three weeks in a row we make arrangements, agree a time, he doesn’t show then silence on the phone.

    Why can’t people just do the thing they say they are going to do?

    Is there any other industry where it is so common for people to be so unreliable and not have basic business norms like a good website, telephone answering, published references, guarantees etc.?

    bigblackshed
    Full Member

    It’s one of the first things the building trade learn. How to piss off paying customers.

    franksinatra
    Full Member

    It always feels like you are asking for a favour rather than being a paying customer

    Fresh Goods Friday 696: The Middling Edition

    Fresh Goods Friday 696: The Middlin...
    Latest Singletrack Videos
    geoffj
    Full Member

    And Brexit is only going to make it worse.

    dirksdiggler
    Free Member

    I have pretty much said the work is his

    makes him complacent

    and

    I know he does a good job

    probably means he’s already beyond his work capacity if he has this reputation

    Perhaps for him to be able to meet demand, he needs a reliable working colleague.. which as he cant find, he cant grow and satisfy demand hes created by being good?

    deadlydarcy
    Free Member

    We’re not all like that! 🙂

    Anyway, I noticed you said this…

    I know he does a good job so I have pretty much said the work is his.

    Maybe he now feels he doesn’t have to try to hard to “win” the work. (Which is not to excuse him but y’know…)One missed appointment is forigiveable. Two and three are not (IMO). Sometimes it’s hard to give people bad news – and some guys adopt an ostrich approach.

    All that said, I have, in the past, just had to ignore people whose jobs I didn’t want to do until they stopped pestering me.

    franksinatra
    Full Member

    I have pretty much said the work is his

    makes him complacent
    and
    I know he does a good job

    probably means he’s already beyond his work capacity if he has this reputation
    Perhaps for him to be able to meet demand, he needs a reliable working colleague.. which as he cant find, he cant grow and satisfy demand hes created by being good?

    Perhaps correct on both fronts, but no excuse. IF he doesn’t want the work, can’t do it or is too busy, then just tell me. Don’t arrange to come out to the house and not turn up, three times!

    franksinatra
    Full Member

    All that said, I have, in the past, just had to ignore people whose jobs I didn’t want to do until they stopped pestering me.

    Did you tell them that you didn’t want to do the work? I wouldn’t have an issue with that at all, I would rather know up front.

    deadlydarcy
    Free Member

    Did you tell them that you didn’t want to do the work?

    No, I didn’t. I just ignored them until they stopped pestering me. 🙂

    petefromearth
    Full Member

    All that said, I have, in the past, just had to ignore people whose jobs I didn’t want to do until they stopped pestering me.

    I find this particularly annoying. I’d rather people were up front, if they are too busy and don’t want the work then say so. Having to chase someone even to quote or commit to a date doesn’t bode well. I normally give up on them if I feel like I’m the one doing the chasing.

    I understand good people get busy though. And I bet there’s a fair few dead end quotes as well.

    Blazin-saddles
    Free Member

    I’m pretty much always booked 2-3 months in advance. When I get a call I try to look at the job in a timely manner still, but make sure the potential customer is aware nothing is going to be happening until whatever date, which I try to stick to as close as possible.

    Not turning up for a pre arranged appointment once, let alone 3 times, without a phone call in unacceptable in my books.

    I do get a lot of people however, that expect you to be sitting at home waiting for their call to come and have a look. Quoting often has to wait until the weekend as I don’t have any other time to do it.

    bearnecessities
    Full Member

    It always feels like you are asking for a favour rather than being a paying customer

    Ahmen.

    Crap tradesmen that are crap – readily available.

    Not quite as crap tradesmen – arse you about.

    Decent tradesmen that are not crap – 6 month waiting list.

    I’d happily pay £300 + a day for anyone if they turn up and just do the job, properly.

    I will defend them to a point though, as most people are dicks and I couldn’t fancy doing work for the majority of the public 🙂

    As far as the phone answering / getting back to you thing, I have some sympathy with that – they are specialist in a trade, not necessarily skilled in running a business.

    Richard, still with a chimney that pisses water into the hearth because of above 🙁

    Edit:

    He’s getting a review on his trust a trader

    IME if they are on any kind of site like that, they’re crap.

    woollybackpaul
    Free Member

    I know the feeling…..

    Having a brick shed built, walls are up, just needs the roof and door sorting.

    Four no shows so far and the twunt never answers his phone but then texts me with his next promise / latest excuse.

    He’s getting a review on his trust a trader / Facebook pages if he doesn’t show up on Monday.

    deadlydarcy
    Free Member

    I normally give up on them if I feel like I’m the one doing the chasing.

    My kinda guy! 🙂

    jimjam
    Free Member

    I had a similar experience to the OP with getting a bathroom floor tiled and have had many similar experiences with mechanics. I’m musing here but I think this behavior flourishes because the margins between standards are quite small.

    Tradesmen who are really good will presumably expand and quickly be pricing themselves out of smaller jobs in relatively short time, so as a private householder you’re left with people who are content to stay small, take on smaller jobs or people who perhaps aren’t good enough or don’t have the desire to move past that.

    I mean, if you can get someone who is semi literate, answers his phone and gives a quote somewhere in the ballpark of what you expected then that’s probably good enough so that’s the standard you end up with.

    nosedive
    Free Member

    Ive had this all year (though found some good people in the end just in case the top bloke who did my extension is reading). Ive learnt to be wary of anyone who answers the phone / turns up on time / can start next week. They usually seem to be really shite or not even doing the work themselves.

    chickenman
    Full Member

    I don’t answer my phone during the working day, all that happens is that you make arrangements to see people that are simply not practical. I like people to text me; I might take a while to respond but when I will suggest a time which doesn’t mean I have to leave a job unfinished in order to spend 3/4 hour in traffic crossing town to make the appointment.
    Are you happy to pay someone £30/hour to be on his/her phone half the day doing admin for other jobs?
    The fact is there is a massive shortage of people doing trades; it’s not something youngsters aspire to. Once the Poles all leave the situation will get worse.
    I agree it is very unprofessional not to turn up for an appointment. I forget maybe once every couple of years but will always call to apologise as soon as I remember.

    fanatic278
    Free Member

    All the above is so true. But what gets me is why when you do managed to get 2 or 3 quotes, how can they vary so wildly. Just had a patio installed and got quotes ranging from £7k to £13k! It’s just a patio for Christ’s sake – I provided the design, specced the stones, and gave exact dimensions.

    5plusn8
    Free Member

    TL:DR however what I do know is when you find a good one, be nice, forgive them for the odd mistake and pay them pronto. You will miss them when they are gone.

    DT78
    Free Member

    Same here. Plus I’m getting rip off merchants. One guy says whole flue needs replacing at £1k another guy says to just replace the seal and bracket at £100. I currently have one chap wanting me to commit to a date for a job, he hasn’t even confirmed if he can access the roof in that location or a price…

    I reckon I would make a killing as a trade just by doing what I said I would when I said I would

    rone
    Full Member

    Absolutely OP. My number one 1st world pieve. If I ran my business like they do I would be out of business.

    Have you tried checkatrade?

    poolman
    Free Member

    I stay loyal to regular guys, so same trades each time. Anyone new i need some collateral with, best to overpay which i probably do but the price is soon forgotten when the jobs done well. Buy cheap buy twice.

    jambourgie
    Free Member

    As a self employed person myself, I hate talking on the phone with customers. I can understand why they prefer it; presumably so they can get answers to eighteen questions in a thirty second phone call.

    But for me, i’d rather correspondence was via text or email. Apart from the fact that I’m generally WORKING when they call. The main reason being is that there is a record of everything discussed that you can refer to at any given time. From dates and addresses, to quantities and specifications. It’s all there.

    deadlydarcy
    Free Member

    I’m generally WORKING when they call

    But theirs is the ONLY job anywhere that needs doing this year. You should be flattered. 🙂

    wilburt
    Free Member

    Ditto, three weeks to find a bathroom fitter, quoted me two weeks and a price. After 10 days he was no where near done and wanting more money.
    Sacked him, next one turned up three days later than arranged so sacked him too.
    Ended uo fitting it myself, peice of piss. They are having giraffe so to speak.

    There not as bad as heating engineers though who are all psychopaths, thats why they work for themselves.

    angeldust
    Free Member

    I hate to generalise, because there are loads of good tradesmen out there too…..

    …..but how many of them are in the trade because they can’t be trusted to be reliable in a professional environment, where they would be accountable for their performance?

    Before anyone explodes, I’ll stress I’m aware there are good, professional tradesmen too, amongst the sea of crap ones. In other Countries you need formal qualifications to call yourself a builder or similar, unlike some of the cowboys we get here.

    marcus
    Free Member

    I’m not sure it’s just Tradesman. Certainly in my experience ‘anything’ done in construction and development, including all professional services is done last minute and testing the respective Client / bill payers patience to within an inch of them snapping.

    deadlydarcy
    Free Member

    ….but how many of them are in the trade because they can’t be trusted to be reliable in a professional environment, where they would be accountable for their performance?

    I’d certainly put myself in that category.

    totalshell
    Full Member

    let me hit the other side of the fence button.. woken at 04.58 one morning this week to a text from someone i ve never heard of.. ”can you fit a shower today pref this a.m.” twelve times a bloke rang and left a message every single time.. because he didnt know if he needed batteries in his timer that hes had for 3 years.. today attend a shower not working call.. turns it on shower runs for 3 minute 40 seconds and stops ..” there.. you ve broken it, im not paying to have it fixed” and the worst trend.. folks now wanting written quotes for boiler repairs.. would you travel to a property.. tools out, diagnose fault, reassemble, travel home to write a quote for a 65 quid repair..?? website NO No No all you get are people who now how to do everything telling you the best way to do the job you ve done for 20 years.. i dont do ads. websites. and get by nicely on word of mouth by been cheap, cheerful and nice to old folks.. 🙂

    Joe
    Full Member

    I’m going through it at the moment. The romanians/poles turn up within 30 minutes of you calling them and want to start the same day. Brits tend not to, although most people i call tend to come around and quote on the job. I’ve had good and i’ve had shit with both approaches. The Romanians tend to really push for the work. Some of them are charlatans, but many are decent workmen. I had an Asian plasterer in yesterday, who agreed to labour for me today (…HE didn’t have work today and was keen to just have a day’s work). He turned up at 0700 both mornings and worked like a beast until 1900 this evening hauling concrete in and out of the house in buckets.

    The most amazing thing is how many differnet opinions there are to solve basic problems…and wildly different prices. Trying to get a patio done (THANK god one of the final jobs) and really unsure at who to go with…

    …but think of it from the tradesmen’s point of view. People with google at their fingers, call loads of people, get loads of quotes…you traipse round town quoting on jobs after doing a long day of work yourself and then are expected to take odd jobs here and there at a day rate which equals a salary that most office workers would sneer at.

    As for the person above who said “it’s easy”; DON’T be so **** riduclous. How can you claim that the trades are easy? Everything is easy when you know how. I am pretty competant when it comes to most general building tasks, but stuff like bricklaying/plastering aren’t worth my while and the difference between an amateur job and a pro one espeically when it comes to finishing is night/day.

    Joe
    Full Member

    let me hit the other side of the fence button.. woken at 04.58 one morning this week to a text from someone i ve never heard of.. ”can you fit a shower today pref this a.m.” twelve times a bloke rang and left a message every single time.. because he didnt know if he needed batteries in his timer that hes had for 3 years.. today attend a shower not working call.. turns it on shower runs for 3 minute 40 seconds and stops ..” there.. you ve broken it, im not paying to have it fixed” and the worst trend.. folks now wanting written quotes for boiler repairs.. would you travel to a property.. tools out, diagnose fault, reassemble, travel home to write a quote for a 65 quid repair..?? website NO No No all you get are people who now how to do everything telling you the best way to do the job you ve done for 20 years.. i dont do ads. websites. and get by nicely on word of mouth by been cheap, cheerful and nice to old folks..

    I sympathise with you.

    pk13
    Full Member

    Heating engineer got called on Monday came to look wends with a 1 hour time slot diagnosed the problem coming back next week to replace the boiler as it goosed.
    Sorted

    esselgruntfuttock
    Free Member

    I had it with a ‘reliable/excellent’ tiler. Needed a kitchen & bathroom doing but he had a 3 month waiting list. I was OK with that, some other stuff needed doing. 2 weeks before he was due he emailed to say it would be another 2 weeks as his current job was running over, fine I can go with that. 2 days before the reviewed date he emails to say he can’t actually do it at all, no reason at the time but he’s still in business.
    Then emails again to ask why I’d given him 1/10 on a review site. 🙄

    sr0093193
    Free Member

    Have phone number for work. Get indigent when people use it to contact you about work. 🙄

    newrobdob
    Free Member

    I hate talking on the phone with customers.

    Seriously??? I don’t expect someone to be available 24/7 but a ring back would be nice.

    I’ve tried texting tradesmen but that almost never gets a reply. 🙁

    I think a lot of tradesmen are operating like it’s the 1970’s still.

    deadlydarcy
    Free Member

    I think a lot of tradesmen are operating like it’s the 1970’s still.

    Certainly felt that way when Mrs Johnson commented on how hot it was in her house last week.

    redmex
    Free Member

    Checkatrade and trusted trader rated people they are a laugh so many dodgy folk on them a bit like the guild of master craftsmen from years ago as long as you pay the money anyone can join
    If you see ads that start gutters cleaning then monoblocks upvc facias then eventually more serious stuff beware as the can’t or shouldn’t be doing it
    It is tricky but word of mouth is probably best, avoid those that turn up in trainers to work in construction or look like they ate all the pies

    project
    Free Member

    Is there any other industry where it is so common for people to be so unreliable and not have basic business norms like a good website, telephone answering, published references, guarantees etc.?

    the NHS/ gp surgeries etc

    geoffj
    Full Member

    Certainly felt that way when Mrs Johnson commented on how hot it was in her house last week.

    😯

    project
    Free Member

    AS one of these tradesmen,2 nights at 22.30 woken up by phone call asking how much to fit 2 internal doors, had to get up to answer the phone but it went to voicemail before i found the phone.

    Last night 2315 another call went to voicemail just heavy breathing, again had to got up to check phone.

    3 months ago went to a customers house measured up and drew out what they wanted delivered estimate a few days latter, 7 weeks latter they deciided to go ahead with part 1 at a cost of 100 quid.

    3 weeks ago they decided to go ahead with part b cost 95.00 quid bought materials, materials increased in price, decided not to charge extra, day of job they rang up to totally change specifiation, they would now buy materials, had to then return materials as not needed , hassle, havent heard anything since.

Viewing 40 posts - 1 through 40 (of 173 total)

The topic ‘What is wrong with tradesmen?’ is closed to new replies.