Viewing 40 posts - 14,921 through 14,960 (of 18,775 total)
  • Ukraine
  • gofasterstripes
    Free Member

    Doesn’t look like it’s going very fast as the prop is freewheeling slowly before it’s whacked.

    Nb the damage is one bent and one twisted blade. They’re variable angle and it’s out of position

    stumpy01
    Full Member

    gofasterstripes
    Free Member
    Doesn’t look like it’s going very fast as the prop is freewheeling slowly before it’s whacked.

    I assumed the apparent slow rotation speed is just a strobing artefact from the video footage? I’m not sure you can easily ascertain the actual prop speed from that vid.

    They could have downed it with cannon fire or a missile without any risk to the jet. The collision only happened because the pilot was dicking around and cocked up.

    Firing on an aircraft, uncrewed or otherwise, in international airspace is going initiate a response.

    Hence the recklessness instead of very overt armed aggression.

    The Reaper like the Predator before it all have zeroise protocols both manual and automatic to erase all data held onboard.

    The homeplate is where the recording from the sensors is done, along with routing data, etc.

    I assumed the apparent slow rotation speed is just a strobing artefact from the video footage? I’m not sure you can easily ascertain the actual prop speed from that vid.

    Think I have a video somewhere of one, let me see if I can find it.

    slowoldman
    Full Member

    Global Hawks have been in use over the Black Sea since the beginning of the war.

    chewkw
    Free Member

    How many “weather balloons” can you have for $32 million I wonder.

    Caher
    Full Member

    99.

    chewkw
    Free Member

    99.

    I wonder if Nena would agree at that price.

    scaredypants
    Full Member

    I believe she said “99 red balloons – go buy”

    thols2
    Full Member

    This example shows the difference between normal surveillance operations and illegal provocations. Countries are allowed to operate their ships in international waters. Nobody has a problem with that. Trying to screw up commercial aircraft communications and navigation equipment is illegal provocations. China is upset that Australia is buying nuclear powered submarines so they are flexing their muscles to show that they can disrupt the region if they feel like it and that other countries are too scared to retaliate militarily.

    shermer75
    Free Member

    I believe she said “99 red balloons – go buy”

    👏👏👏

    kimbers
    Full Member

    The mad effort to carry out Putin’s order & capture all of Donetsk Oblast by the end of March is looking increasingly unlikely to succeed yet cost Russia huge numbers of soldiers

    breatheeasy
    Free Member

    Seven to one ratio of RU vs UKR killed in Bahkmut apparently.

    Gruesome tactics – send out a group of conscripts armed with a sharp stick and a woolly hat for protection. Make a note of where the gunfire that mows them down comes from. Shoot at said position. Repeat.

    singletrackmind
    Full Member

    Been reading a book on Stalingrad..
    The Russian side ability for suffering and losses is staggering. On a scale many times what is happening in Ukraine. Its very similar in that the weather amd tactics play a significant part in the way attacks are planned and executed.
    But the numbers….. WW2 was another level of destruction altogether

    thols2
    Full Member

    Been reading a book on Stalingrad..
    The Russian side ability for suffering and losses is staggering.

    Russia is a different country now. Putin shares Stalin’s utter lack of concern for human life, but Russians really did face an existential threat back then. Germany’s policy of genocide in Eastern Europe meant that surrender just meant death anyway, so you might as well just fight to the death. In this war, Ukraine is in the same position – surrender means genocide, so they aren’t going to surrender. Russia, as a country, does not face an existential threat, they could just withdraw their soldiers and the war would be over. Putin is keeping this going for his own fantasies of being remembered as the man who rebuilt the Russian empire, but the soldiers on the ground know how pointless their attacks are. Their morale must be utterly nonexistent, they are forced at gunpoint to make suicidal attacks on Ukrainian positions for the sake of a few meters of ground. All they are doing is frittering their army away, they aren’t making any useful gains.

    timba
    Free Member

    Russia is a different country now

    Arguably not. When Germany invaded Poland in 1939, Russia embarked on a pre-war agreement with Germany to split E.Europe and invaded E.Poland a couple of weeks later, followed by Finland, parts of the Baltic states and Romania.
    Russia didn’t formally declare war then, as now; they annexed Polish territory, its people and held rigged elections
    It wasn’t until 1941 that Germany invaded the Soviet Union and Russians faced an existential threat

    piemonster
    Full Member

    In addition to that.

    The population of the Soviet Union in 1940 has been estimated at 194 million, today the Russian Federation has a population of 143 million.

    In 1950 the median age is estimated as 23.37, 2020 was 38.6

    Millions of those Russian casualties weren’t Russian at all, Ukraine and others formed large parts of the Red Army and even greater parts of civilian deaths as the western parts of the Soviet Union fell to the Nazis.

    The Russians have no innate ability to suffer more than their former Soviet dominions do. Nor have they really exceeded the misery inflicted on their former Soviet dominions.

    Ukraine itself was conquered by both Hitler and Stalin with brutal repression of dissent inflicted by two of the worst human beings to ever have existed.

    singletrackmind
    Full Member

    Some interesting graphics on twitr showing Russian tank losses. Pinch of salt on the actual numbers but they claim to be hitting more armour every day.
    With total numbers into 4 figures, now i dont know if that includes tracked APC types too. As most people call anything big, green and heavy with any gun on top a tank.
    I don’t know how many serviceable units they started with, but they must be running out of replacement units as Western MBTs are deployed
    Talks of dropping tear gas from drones into trenches, which is worrying

    futonrivercrossing
    Free Member

    According to the Oryx website, which a has photographic evidence of each kill;

    As of today Russia has lost 1854 tanks, of which 550 were captured

    Out of a total 9678 AFV lost.

    Mind boggling 😵‍💫

    piemonster
    Full Member

    Ummm…

    matt_outandabout
    Full Member

    Well I giggled.

    piemonster
    Full Member

    Ive not seen this anywhere else apart from LCI and a very pro Ukrainian account, if anyone can verify itd be appreciated

    https://twitter.com/LCI/status/1637187448072552449?t=Dj4NkQ0esEEEwxm3BXGHnA&s=09

    If Ukraine fails to defend its independence, we will have no choice, we will be forced to enter the conflict,” says Jan Emeryk Rościszewski, Polish Ambassador to France

    pk13
    Full Member

    I don’t think Poland can stomach being in that position again even with NATO behind them so I can see why going on the offence is better than waiting for 100thou Russia troupes at the boarder.
    The stakes are frightening

    timba
    Free Member

    If Ukraine fails to defend its independence, we will have no choice, we will be forced to enter the conflict,” says Jan Emeryk Rościszewski, Polish Ambassador to France

    It’s literal, “If Ukraine fails to defend its independence…” i.e if Russia “wins”

    The peoples of Poland and Ukraine haven’t had the best history as neighbours, but they both detest the Russian State far more.
    Recent pre-invasion polls have shown a more mellow view of Ukrainians https://www.cbos.pl/PL/publikacje/public_opinion/2022/02_2022.pdf

    matt_outandabout
    Full Member

    It’s literal, “If Ukraine fails to defend its independence…” i.e if Russia “wins”

    If Russia starts advancing considerably in Ukraine, I do wonder what the west / NATO / close neighbours will do.

    rickmeister
    Full Member

    From Twitter yesterday, signs of Russian drones dropping Satellite distress beacons on AFU positions. The Russians own the satellites these are linked to so pull the data for targeting info….

    Obvious solution is obvious… Ukraine drone fly it back across to the Russian camp.

    molgrips
    Free Member

    Eh? If you have dropped a beacon in a UKR position, then you must have known where that position is in the first place to have flown a drone there?

    DT78
    Free Member

    maybe they know the rough location, fly the drone over to drop the beacon to be more accurate.

    matt_outandabout
    Full Member

    Eh? If you have dropped a beacon in a UKR position, then you must have known where that position is in the first place to have flown a drone there?

    Homebrew self guided something or other which uses the emergency beacon system?

    thisisnotaspoon
    Free Member

    Homebrew self guided something or other which uses the emergency beacon system?

    Would make more sense, EPIRB’s have a system that sends out a literal ‘ping’ on their frequency so you can locate them by just waving a directional antennae+ receiver and headphones around and walking towards wherever the signal is strongest.

    The EPRIB satellite system IIRC works like a reverse GPS, the satellites receive the ping, and calculate between them where it came from, It’s not very accurate, hence the 2nd method of doing it on the ground once you’ve got rescue teams within some proximity.

    It’s not like SPOT/InReach which uses GPS location and transmits them over a satellite phone link.

    thols2
    Full Member

    Would it not be fairly easy to jam or interfere with the locater beacon. Surely, all you’d need to do is mimic the signal at a different location or multiple locations and the detector wouldn’t know which one to follow.

    hatter
    Full Member

    Been reading a book on Stalingrad..
    The Russian side ability for suffering and losses is staggering.

    Another factor not mentioned above is modern communications, at Stalingrad Russian troops had no way to communicate with their families back home, no phones and what few letters got through were heavily censored. The folks back home were largely unaware of how their sons were being treated.

    Now, even with the Russia state doing it’s best to filter out bad news, news of conditions at the front and the horrendous casualties is filtering back, hence why so many fled the draft, why recruiting office keep catching fire and why Putin has been so careful to avoid drafting Muscovites whose families may have connections.

    Russia’s resolve tends to look utterly unbreakable… until one day it suddenly isn’t, see Afghanistan for instance.

    thisisnotaspoon
    Free Member

    I guess. But then it would depend on how clever whatever kit the Russians are using is.

    I don’t design bombs, but hypothetically if I did and was using that sort of guidance, then I’d probably design it to fly to a target with +/- 50m accuracy (because you obviously know where it is), then aim directly at the beacon which I’d just dropped on some weak point. A bit like laser guided munitions, but without actually having to hang around.

    matt_outandabout
    Full Member

    So what do we think of Xi’s visit?

    Seems that either: he is going to do nada, other than some quiet increase in supplying Russia with ‘things’ or there may, just may, be a word to back off to the benefit of all…?

    hatter
    Full Member

    I suspect it’ll be a combination of a public show of solidarity with a fair bit of ‘WTF are you playing at Vlad?’ Going on behind closed doors.

    thols2
    Full Member

    So what do we think of Xi’s visit?

    He’s trying to figure out what’s best for him. Weakening the U.S., NATO, etc. will be his top priority, but he also needs to manage relations with the West. Putin started a disastrous war and is losing badly, China’s not going to throw it’s hat in with a losing cause but they might prop him up just enough to get cheap oil and keep NATO distracted. Xi will do whatever he thinks is best for China, he has no loyalty to Putin.

    thols2
    Full Member

    Putin owes money to the mob.

    kimbers
    Full Member

    https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/ukraine-says-russia-cruise-missiles-blown-up-transit-crimea-2023-03-20/

    kimbers
    Full Member

    More drones

    thols2
    Full Member

    This is obviously unconfirmed, but just the fact that it’s quite likely true is an indication of how badly Russia is doing.

    https://twitter.com/TheDeadDistrict/status/1638476582879731713

Viewing 40 posts - 14,921 through 14,960 (of 18,775 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.