I’m really enjoying mine, I have the XL. I’ve gone from an ASR5 to the Smuggler so a bit of a transition (boom tish) to getting used to big wheels, also it’s heavier and bigger than what I was used to, but I don’t notice the weight increase very often now I’m used to it.
It’s a very capable bike for the travel and is far more capable than me, on faster open trails eg the DH trails at Innerleithen it really wants to go like stink and is very confidence inspiring, and the big wheels feel great over loose rough stuff like the baby heads on the Ciaran path. On really tight steep stuff it does take a bit more rider input than the 26″ bike did but the rear end is very short, not far off my old bike, and it turns really nicely.
Being very tall with a long body the frame fits me really well, it has really long reach, it’s the first bike that has ever properly fitted me I think, but the relatively short seat tube and good standover means you can still move around with ease and it is nothing like a farm gate in XL. I find it much easier to get good weight on the front end than on my ASR5, really fun in the corners and quite easy to get the back sliding around if that amuses you too.
There are still some to be had in 2015, if you are near Edinburgh I got mine from pedals and they’ll be able to tell you what is still left. One of the guys there has also just bought a Smuggler.
The only negative I’ve found is some big rear tyres come very close to and can touch the seatstay bridge, which is a known issue on the mtbr transition forum, not a showstopper for me so far though and lateral clearance to the side of the tyre is excellent.
Definitely recommended from me anyway