Perhaps the owners pulled it because they were sick of a minority spoiling it for everyone else…
[my partisan view*] That forum was very succesfully moderated for a number of years by a small number of volunteer forum members. Very informative site, good debates, healthy level of banter (to me “banter” is one of the most important but indefinable characteristics of a good forum).
The mods, IMHO, did a very good job, but again IMHO, were not properly appreciated – and when some posters started to over-step the mark the mods questioned what it was all about. Forum owner steps in, heavy handed moderation, site starts to loose its appeal and members drift away. After a hack and half hearted re-build I hardly went back. Seems it’s now gone completely.
Loosing the characters risks loosing the character
* – partisan view – very much from my perspective. I know others on here have come from the same place, and respect that they may / will have a different view or recollection… 😉
ETA
I think MTB-Wales was mostly run by one guy (Phil Lee) and when he stepped back from it, it waned
Have to disagree strongly with this. The site flourished for 4-5 (?) years after Phil was drawn away by “other interests”. The mods over that period were never properly credited.