Scenery-wise it is the nicest setting I have ridden in. Absolutely stunning, including wild(?) ponies in Bowderdale itself.
The slog up from Sedbergh is offset by the views. When we rode Bowderdale it was after a prolonged wet spell and it was horrendous. As stated above it was built up massively, and was a massive disappointment. There are some fun bits on the return leg, but not enough to offset the disappointment. We also spent a long time in that field at the north end of the loop!
I do want to go back, though. It needs to be after a good month of very dry weather and I will consider it.
English section of trail better than Bowderdale (on a purely riding basis – ignoring the views).
Minton Batch
Cut Gate (anywhere in the Dark Peak if we’re honest)
Descent from Old Cote Moor top to Litton in the Dales
The list would be long for me – but if you take scenery into account then Bowderdale is back in contention – it really is that nice.