That Cregan creature….
my work is just around the corner from the court. it was mad here this morning; armed police all over the place, helicopter up above for ages, roads all closed.
i’m not surprised he gave himself up. he knew he’d get caught sooner or later; doing what he did meant he’ll achieve more notoriety and he also avoided being seriously hurt or killed himself.Posted 5 years ago
That’s my question really, cb. I understand that some people think that prison is expensive and doesn’t work. I understand that some people aren’t comfortable with “vindictive” based punishments. I want to understand what the alternative would be for clearly violent and dangerous criminals like Cregan.Posted 5 years agoMunqe-chickMember
Peajay…they were going to a “routine” burglary, there was no intelligence on the address they attended and if there had been an ounce or sniff of him (refuse to name him) being at the address then they would not have got sent. It came in as a straight forward burglary of which a double crewed normal response car would be sent to look into it, which tragically is what they did.
Prison doesn’t work and rehabilitation (at least the systems we have in place at present) DO NOT WORK. I know this from experience, the majority of the people we are talking about are huge drugs users, like other things they have to want to stop taking the drugs, they don’t want to then nothing will work. Wrecker, unfortunately who knows what the alternative is… I guess hard labour?? death? that’s a huge heartfelt topic of disucssion that you are opening up! Good luck.Posted 5 years agoJunkyardMember
Can this man be rehabilitated? Should he undergo a non-punishment based programme instead of prison?
Can he be rehabilitated /
possibly but we will never know because he wont be released
Non punishment based programme – I dont know what you mean but I will be surprised if you can find anyone anywhere who thinks he does not deserve punishment
nothing will ever eradicate crime so you can decide if you want to use the birch, deportation and the death penalty or if you want to try and rehabilitate.
it is more a description of the content of your heart/character than it is that you think it will work. Some want vengeance and some offer forgiveness and rehabilitation.
Some serious crimes mean you will never be set free whatever happens and this is clearly one of them [ if he is guilty]Posted 5 years agoallthepiesMember
Appeared in court today and by the looks of the court artist’s sketch was about to get battered!
Posted 5 years agomu3266Member
Possibly all the armed guards are for HIS protection. Lets be honest, if we could get hold of the kit to do him over, a few of us here would have a pop & be hailed heroes for it by the public at large.
Edited to add “at large” as no doubt some of you would attempt the moral high ground and say you wouldn’t.Posted 5 years agomaccruiskeenSubscriber
In response to wrecker. I don’t think anyone suggests that no criminal should go to prison ever for any crime. But there’s a knee jerk tabloid stirred position that every criminal should go to prison for ever for any crime. Prison is a necessary element of preventing crime but it’s not the only tool. If you treat it like it is the only tool then you point us towards the US where sentencing gets ever more punitive and the rate of crime and the prison population gets ever larger.
In the uk a large proportion of offenders are young. So presumably as people get older they either offend less or they get better at it and don’t get caught, but presumably something about our policing and penal system is successful in persuading people who did offend to cease offending.Posted 5 years ago
thanks for the comment maccruiskeen. I have read (here) before that prison simply doesn’t work (etc etc) and that non retribution based rehabilitation should replace it. I understand this. I don’t know where the line could be drawn. People committing fraud often don’t cause physical (or any) harm to others; should they be subject to non-prison sentence? It’s only money after all.Posted 5 years ago
Burglers nearly always cause massive mental damage/stress and sometimes physical too; they must be a shoe in for jail time?v8ninetySubscriber
I’m usually fairly liberal but in the cases of people like this, I can’t help but think euthanasia would be best. Not a vengeful painful killing, just a simple termination of a life that has no place in society, and instead has become a huge burden to it, with no redeeming features. I understand the arguments against capital punishment, and mostly agree with them, but what point keeping him alive?Posted 5 years agorudebwoyMember
sentencing policy can and has been politically motivated, remember all those ‘harsh’ sentences for ‘rioters’, a bottle of water– 6 months– etc
Then look at white collar crime– its only money– often can be a suspended sentence.
The message is clear, don’t mess with property if you are working class.Posted 5 years ago
The topic ‘That Cregan creature….’ is closed to new replies.