Another option: Sadddleworth Valley (Stalybridge, Mossley, Greendfield) None of these have particularly nice town centres but there are nice areas of housing fairly close to train stations. Doorstep Riding / hiking is ace. Several supermarkets in the area. Quite a few schools and a swimming pool!
I have lived in Mossley, Stalybridge, Hayfield and Broadbottom. All have great riding – only the commute from hayfield was painful.
Glossop train is electric. I currently live in Broadbottom on that line. Train is busy in the morning but not horrendous – wife gets train in every day.
I now work in Leeds and usually get train there from Stalybridge(ride or drive to Staly) – its transpennine train and only occasionally disrupted. It runs through to manc and also some of their services now stop in Mossley or Greenfield.
I’ve considered Todd / Heb – but if there is a problem with trains or you need to drive for some other reason it looks like a traffic ball-ache.