@thisisnotaspoon, you are correct, measured durometer isn’t everything, but all of the ones I see (except Spesh and Vittoria) use compounds listed as ~60a, or known low grip names, like Schwalbe Speedgrip.
So basically, I would take anything listed as less than 60a, or some kind of medium grip name, like Speedgrip, Maxterra etc.
I agree, I am keeping regular drop bars on this bike, not turning it into a drop bar mtb.
I maybe didn’t write it clearly, I am not looking for >2.1” tires. I am looking for 50-53mm tires, which are often labeled as 2.0 or 2.1” in their name.
I do like my 700×40 minimal tread tires for (gravel) road, but when the hits start coming harder, a bigger tire gives a lot more rim protection, in sand it offers better control, and on all soft or rough surfaces it will be faster than a narrower tire.
In the front, rolling resistance doesn’t count as much as in the rear, so adding some moderate knobs and slightly grippier compound, is a good trade off.
Rear sliding isn’t nearly as bad for my dental health as front sliding!
So personally, I do think that a gravel bike with ~2.0” tires can be the fastest, most fun solution on many tracks.