I have a pair of Sam Hill Nukeproof Horizons which I love, but wouldn’t mind to try some plastic ones someday.
Mine are quite beat up, very few areas left with the original black finish and had to replace 50% of the original pins or so. Bearings/bushings are fine still.
An issue I have with screw through pin pedals like the Horizons is that when you remove a damaged pin you tend to also damage the thread on the pedal body. Doing so property involves first cutting the pin and then unscrewing it, but you don’t always have the tools.
Plastic pedals are better in this regard, the pin screws through a standard nyloc nut on the opposite side, you can easily replace the whole set.
One Up Composites used to be all the rage around here, not hearing much about them lately.
Anyone used both the One Ups and the Horizons?