I don’t know how old your Pikes are, but the earlier version had an issue with the charger damper seal head which allowed oil to leak out and into the lowers. It reduced travel and affected damping – does the three-position semi-lockout work still?
The easy wy to check is to drop the lowers off and see if there’s a shedload of damper oil in the damper-side lower – it’ll be obvious as soon as your release the bolt that locks the damper rod to the bottom of the fork as the oil’ll run out.
When it happened to me I lost travel – the oil in the fork lower means the fork can’t compress – the damping still sort of worked, but not quite right, and the quasi-lockout stopped working properly too.
If you’re certain the air side is okay then you’re going to have to pull the damper anyway, so you might as well drop the lowers off and see. It’ll only take you five minutes and you’ll know for certain whether the damper has dumped oil into the lower. Sticking a zip-tie past the wiper seals won’t tell you that.
Edit: ignore what I said about dropping the lowers. Hadn’t realised you’d done it already. If it were me I’d try bleeding the damper. It’s slightly fiddly, but not particularly difficult.