My heart is veering to a 52 plate Subaru Legacy saloon though – 2.5ltr, again with FSH. But the wife isn’t keen!!!
If you’re talking bangernomics then really think about cars with commonly available parts and commonly known faults.
No car is fault-less but a known-fault is cheaper to fix than repeatedly failing to diagnose a rare fault (the Molgrips syndrome). I’ve got an old astra van, not without its common bugbears but they’ve been about for 15 years every fault is well known by mechanics and cheap aftermarket fixes and refurbishmnets for parts that would otherwise be a write-off are available. So you can have a failure of the whole engine management system (a la Molgrips and his Passat) and rather than a bill of £100s or £1000s for diagnostics, mis-diagnoses and parts, and then wrong parts and then the right parts…. instead its a google of a few old astra forums, £150 and a stamp to send the whole system off in the post, get a refurbished one back then next day and fit it yourself in 15 mins.
For all the positives of subarus a big negative is non-availabiltity of parts – common service items are fine, but if anything else gets broken it can be a problem. My sister-in-laws Legacy got broken in to and the ignition barrel and surrounds fubarred in an attempt to steel it. There were no subaru ignition barrels (of the right spec) or any of the steering column parts in the country and wait of months for anything to turn up, if it ever would. The wait rather than the cost made it uneconomical to repair so she had to scrap it.