[lottoMember]

Not been impressed by my Charge Spoon or Fizik Gobi. Much discomfort to start a seconds day ride on them both. Thinking WTB speed pro, or other recommendations.

[CaptainFlashheartMember]

Almost everyone I know who’s tried a Specialized saddle likes them.

Blingy pimp Phenom is my choice, fitted to my pert posterior, obviously.

[rascalMember]

Charge Spoon…or the very uncomfortable-sounding Charge Knife 😉
I have one on the Trigger and one on the roadie.

[siwhiteSubscriber]

Brooks Cambian scooped job for me. Lurrvley.

[njee20Subscriber]

Spesh +1, although I really like my Bontrager Evoke RXL

[greentrickyMember]

Spesh gets my vote, Charge spoon was horrendous and gave me sores 🙁

[AndyRTSubscriber]

Brooks cambium c17

[jabbiMember]

I have several different saddles lurking about, Fizik Gobi Xm and Bontrager Evoke RL are alright for a couple of hours, battered old Selle Italia Flite is good for about 4 hours but the one that stays comfy for time is a Charge Bucket that cost 8 quid, weighs a ton and frankly looks shite!
The best thing to do, is beg, borrow or steal as many different types as possible till you find what works for you.

[jonny rocky mountainSubscriber]

Spesh henge for me

[robownsSubscriber]

I like my WTB Silverado but it got pretty wobbly on the rails pretty quickly for a £70 quid saddle.

[oink1Subscriber]

Charge spoon or WTB volt for my posterior 🙂

[Jolly Green GiantMember]

You must have a very different arse from me.The Gobi and Fabric Scoop have been great for me, as was Fizik Arione. Less good were the,F Fizik Tundra, wtb speed v and prologo zero.

[unovoloMember]

the one that stays comfy for time is a Charge Bucket that cost 8 quid, weighs a ton and frankly looks shite

Designwise thinks that’s pretty much based on the Selle italia Turbo which I too find comfortable.
That said the most comfortable for me is Selle San Marco REGALe like this…

[funkmasterpSubscriber]

Chromag trailmaster ltd, lovely comfortable leather saddle or SDG Bel Air 2.0.

[deadkennySubscriber]

Spoon… oh 😉

Well, for the majority who love them they’re great. Weird folk is another matter 😛

“Much discomfort to start a seconds day ride on them “

You only gave it a day’s ride to judge?

[davewalshMember]

I’ve also tried a spoon and a gobi and didn’t get on with either of them. I keep going back to the original SDG bel-air. I also have the bel-air 2.0 on one bike but it isn’t as comfy as the original.

[tangMember]

Spesh and astute here. Mind you fabric gave me a new scoop which isn’t bad at all, much nicer than the spoon.

[fd3chrisSubscriber]

Another one for the Chromag Trail master. Comfy and durable and looks good.

[yossarianMember]

Selle Italian SLR is the nicest I’ve used since the original SDG satellite.

[holstMember]

SDG Bel-Air is my long-time favorite.

[pickleMember]

Madison Flux (pretty much the same as a Spoon) the most comfortable saddle I’ve had and only about £20

[reggiegasketMember]

SDG Bel-Air 2.0 here. Mate has a Fabric one that is comfy too.

Spesh Romin on the roadies.

[warpcowMember]

Everyone saw the part in the OP where he said the Charge Spoon didn’t work, right? 😉

I sort of get on with the Spoon, and they’re alright value, but I’ve had too many that began to creak, or where the padding became not very padded very quickly. I went to a Bel Air 2.0 recently and it’s much, much better, especially in terms of comfort.

[mikewsmithSubscriber]

Saddle fitting app
http://flowmountainbike.com/post-all/innovation-saddle-selection-app-unveiled/
(Sort of NSFW)
Answer one that fits, flat better than shaped maybe? Whats the discomfort like?

[Jef WachowchowMember]

I am also in a minority where the Charge Spoon creases me. I have tried many saddles and thought I had found ‘my fit’ when I started using the WTB Pure V (fatty bastard weekend warrior edition).

My latest bike arrived with an ANVL Forge. Honestly the most comfy saddle I have ever tried. I now have one on each of my bikes.

Being super aware how subjective saddle fit can be, I would never recommend one, but would like to share my experience with a lesser known brand that needs more exposure as they are not easy to get hold of at the moment.

[aphex_2kMember]

Anyone tried the charge scoop?

some random old SPESH saddle on my ht and giant connect on my trance. SPESH is way comfier

[aphex_2kMember]

Decent cycling shorts make a huge difference yoo

[big_scot_nannySubscriber]

I’m also in the ‘hell no’ camp for fizik or spoon.

Most comfy saddle by a country mile is the Selle SMP plus – but it’s got a high tail which makes getting off the back, and back on again without snagging a bit trickier than usual.

Second most comfy for my Arse is sdg bel air, although I have managed to snap the rails on 2 of them in crashes.

Third is a specialised thingy that came with my stumpy, but only if wearing my favouritest mostest comfy bib shorts ( castelli), otherwise my taint is rawer then fresh beef tartar. With capers.

[iaincSubscriber]

ISM saddles on all the bikes, either road or mtb versions.